- Before
- Owns the program, the clocks and the monthly board report, and sees forty tickets where there is one problem.
- Now
- Starts the day on the theme strip with the overnight scan done; sends one issue to its owner and approves every response.
One escrow error, from forty complaints to one issue
Kestrel Point Bank took over 6,214 mortgage loans from Brightwater Home Loans on 1 September. Its first escrow statements went out on 8 October. Here is what happens next, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 01Tuesday, 06:19
Ninety days of complaints, lined up with what the bank changed
Joelle Marchetti · Complaints Management LeadJoelle opens Themes: 1,286 complaints from 15 Jul to 12 Oct, grouped into 34 themes, each a 90-day strip of daily bars coloured by channel. Above the strip runs a band of operational events — the 21 Jul app release, the 14 Aug HELOC rate notices, the 1 Sep Brightwater transfer, the 8 Oct escrow statements. The overnight scan read 63 new complaints, and one row is flagged in red.
“Escrow shortage after transfer” 19 → 40 — calls, emails and the CFPB portal · began after the 8 Oct statements · flagged likely systemic.
- 02One click
How the theme grew, and the likely root cause
Theme finder · Root-cause investigatorThe theme holds 40 complaints — 23 calls, 11 emails, 6 CFPB complaints — owner Tom Whitfield. There were no escrow complaints for 37 days after the transfer, until the statements arrived. The proposed cause, at 92 % confidence: the transfer file listed the second-half 2026 property tax as still due on 1 Nov, while Brightwater had already paid it on 27–28 Aug, so the escrow analysis counted it a second time.
Ruled out: a tax-rate rise — Marlow’s 2026 rate rose 1.8 %, about $38 a year.
- 0306:16
Who else is affected, and what is at stake
Root-cause investigatorThe investigator searched all 6,214 transferred loans. 1,140 carry the same false shortage — 812 in Marlow County, 328 in Ashby — $1.59M billed that is not owed, $1,391 a loan on average. Fourteen borrowers already paid it in one sum. And the 1 Nov tax run would pay $3.39M of tax a second time; the file locks on 27 Oct.
1,088 more borrowers got the same statement and have not complained yet.
- 04Received 9 Oct, 19:42
One complaint, in the borrower’s own words
Gloria Ferraro · borrower, CFPB portalGloria’s payment goes from $1,842.17 to $1,966.02 for a $1,486.20 shortage, and she has the county’s receipt for the August payment. The intake reader notes each fact in the margin with its source; the account facts sit beside it. The response is drafted in the bank’s escrow template, every fact cited, on the CFPB clock: first response due 24 Oct, final due 8 Dec.
“Commitments in yellow wait for ISS-2026-031. They turn green when Tom Whitfield accepts the issue.”
- 05Received 12 Oct
An email that is a notice of error
ClassifierHarold Benning writes to servicing that his escrow analysis is in error — the Ashby County taxes were paid on August 28 by Brightwater. The classifier treats the written claim of a servicing error as a notice of error, and the clock keeper sets two dates on business days: acknowledge by 20 Oct, correct or explain by 25 Nov.
- 06Sent and accepted
Forty complaints go to servicing as one issue
Joelle Marchetti · Complaints Management LeadJoelle sends the theme to Tom Whitfield, Head of Mortgage Servicing, as ISS-2026-031: 40 complaints linked, the cited evidence from the transfer file, county ledgers and escrow analyses, and a five-step remediation plan with owners and dates. The first step is to stop the 1 Nov tax disbursement for the 1,140 loans by 27 Oct.
“Tom Whitfield accepted ISS-2026-031 — the hold on the 1 Nov tax run is his first step.”
- 0711 days early
The response goes out, commitments confirmed
Joelle Marchetti · Complaints Management LeadBefore the issue was accepted, “Approve and send” stopped her: the response promises to stop the 1 Nov tax payment and keep the payment at $1,842.17, and the owner had not agreed to that yet. Now the commitments are green. She approves, and the response goes out through the CFPB portal 11 days before the due date.
“The commitments are not confirmed yet” — shown when a response promises what the issue owner has not accepted.
- 0808:44
A new email, routed in 3.3 seconds
Intake reader · Classifier · Clock keeperAnother borrower writes in: Corinne Haverford, loan ending 6619, a $1,418.60 shortage and a payment up $118.22, saying Brightwater paid her Marlow County taxes in August. Pasted into “Add a complaint”, it is read, coded mortgage servicing · escrow · shortage dispute, logged as a notice of error, joined to the escrow theme, given its acknowledge and resolve dates, and a reply is drafted.
“Routed in 3.3 s — joined the escrow theme, clock started, response drafted.”
- 09In review
A small theme with a fair lending flag
Anika Sorensen · Fair Lending OfficerSix applicants at the Eastfield and Palo Verde branches say they were told to bring a co-signer after asking for service in Spanish. The theme carries a fair lending flag and goes to Anika as FLR-2026-007: pull the 41 applications at both branches since 1 Sep and compare co-signer requests by language preference, interview the branch managers, then decide — finding or not.
Only the Fair Lending Officer can clear a fair lending flag.
- 10October report
The board report, drafted from the themes and issues
Carmen Ibáñez · Chief Compliance OfficerThe October trend report is drafted for the board compliance committee: complaints by month and channel, themes up and down against the 30 days before, and issues found and fixed — the escrow issue, late fees inside the 60-day transfer window, the fair lending review, and the mobile-app posting fix holding since 2 Sep. The summary can be edited before it is exported.
“Every CFPB complaint was answered within 15 days; 6 escrow responses are due from 24 Oct.”