- Before
- “I spend forty minutes finding the page, and two minutes deciding.” Every dispute starts with which amendment was in force.
- Now
- Opens each dispute with its rate card, the cause and a cited draft response; signs, sends and releases reprocessing in one step.
One knee replacement, from the rate card to 47 claims reprocessed
Brightwater Orthopaedic Partners billed a total knee arthroplasty, CPT 27447, for a date of service of 14 August 2026. Cedar Valley Health Plan paid it $1,514.00. Here is what happens next, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 01One question
Provider, code, date of service — and the rate card
Renata Okoye · Provider dispute analystRenata fills four slots: Brightwater Orthopaedic Partners, 27447, 14 Aug 2026, facility · locality 03. The card answers $1,726.00: the 2026 Medicare physician fee schedule amount of $1,380.80 × 125%, set by Amendment 3 §2.1 on page 4, effective 1 Jul 2026. Four signed entries are in force; one draft is ignored. Multiple-procedure, assistant-surgeon, global-period and prompt-payment terms sit beside it, each with its source.
How this card was built — 3.6 s: contract reader, rate resolver, payment policies, paid-claims checker, rate setup auditor. “Every figure opens its page.”
- 02Checked last night
The card checks what was actually paid
Paid-claims checkerUnder the rate sits the paid claim: 2026-0814-55102, member J. Marlow, billed $4,850.00, paid $1,514.00 on 2 Sep 2026 — $212.00 under the contract rate. The cause is named: rate setup row BOP-PROF-B still reads “118% of 2024 schedule”. 47 claims like it since 1 Jul 2026, $8,249.62 under; prompt-pay interest on this claim is $2.65 if it is reprocessed by 14 Oct.
Amendment 4, a bundled knee and hip episode rate of $14,900, is on the ledger as “Draft — not applied.”
- 03Drag the date
Slide back to June, and the old rate returns
Renata Okoye · Provider dispute analystThe amendment ledger stacks the base agreement and Amendments 1 to 4 by effective date. Renata drags the date to 20 Jun 2026: the rate falls to $1,514.00, Amendment 3 turns “Not yet in force” and the base agreement’s Exhibit B — 118% of the 2024 schedule, “the year is fixed” — sets the rate again. That is exactly what rate setup still pays.
- 04One click
The clause, on its page
Renata Okoye · Provider dispute analyst“Set by Amendment 3 · §2.1 · page 4” opens the signed amendment with §2.1, §2.2 and the effective-date clause highlighted, signed on 18 Jun 2026 by Priya Nandakumar for the plan and Dr. Elena Varga for the group. Margin notes show the arithmetic, that the schedule year moves each 1 January, and that the term applies by date of service, not by paid date.
“Effective by date of service — claims with service on or after 1 Jul 2026 — not by paid date.”
- 05Every night
Paid vs contract, across the plan
Paid-claims checkerEvery paid claim is compared with its rate card each night: 96,214 claims in 90 days, tolerance $5.00 or 1%. 573 are off contract at 8 providers — $88,503.86 under, $9,223.98 over. For Brightwater the rate setup auditor names the cause and lists the 47 claims across six surgical codes, ready to send to reprocessing.
“Agents never adjust a claim — reprocessing is released by a person.”
- 06Dispute in
The dispute arrives with its answer drafted
Dispute response writerBrightwater’s revenue cycle team files DSP-2026-1187 on 22 Sep, asking for $1,726.00 with interest. The dispute opens with the rate card, what reprocessing pays — $212.00 + $2.65 on this claim, $8,249.62 + $96.18 on all 47 — and a drafted response that upholds it under Amendment 3 §2.1 and Section 7.4, with a citation on every statement.
“We have also identified 46 further claims paid at the earlier rate since 1 July and will reprocess them with this one, without a further dispute from you.”
- 07Signed with 10 days left
Sign, send, reprocess 47 claims
Renata Okoye · Provider dispute analystRenata reads the draft and signs. In one step the response goes to Brightwater through the provider portal with three cited pages attached, reprocessing is released for 47 claims — $8,249.62 + $96.18 interest — and a change request for row BOP-PROF-B goes to Diane Castellanos.
- 08Tonight 02:10
The exact row, the exact change, test-priced
Diane Castellanos · Rate configuration leadThe rate setup auditor reads 14,880 setup rows against 2,418 agreements and finds 8 that differ from the signed terms. Each change request names the row, the change, the source page and the claims it corrects — and is test-priced on five sample claims before it reaches Diane. The auditor never changes setup itself.
“Repriced 5 sample claims — all match the rate card.” Waiting for Diane Castellanos.
- 09At renewal
Three orthopaedic groups, side by side
Priya Nandakumar · Network contract managerFor negotiation Priya compares Brightwater with Summit Ridge Orthopedics and Kestrel Bone & Joint Clinic on eight codes, each cell the rate in force on 14 Aug 2026 under that group’s own agreement. For 27447: $1,726.00, $1,656.96 and $1,795.04.
“For negotiation: Kestrel’s surgery rate is 5 points above Brightwater’s.”
- 10Every month
What the contracts are costing — found, not guessed
Network and claims leadership$97,727.84 paid off contract in 90 days, by cause — an amendment signed but never loaded, last year’s schedule still in setup, a payment policy revision missed. 1,846 rate cards asked October to date, a median 9 s to a cited rate, and 31 of 31 disputes answered on time this quarter.