- Before
- Screens a sample of the roster by hand, pulls rates at sender level, and writes the memo from email threads.
- Now
- Opens a review already prepared on all 1,240 originators, reads five chips on a calm tree, and spends the time on what they mean.
A payroll third-party sender's annual review, roster to committee decision
The sender, a payroll processor, has originated ACH through the bank for years. Its annual review is due at the end of the month; it sends for 1,240 companies, 412,000 entries a month, $186.4 million. Here is what happens, screen by screen, in the working solution.
A worked example on sample data. Names, IDs and figures on the screens and in this section come from the demo.
- 01The review that is due
The sender at the top, its originators underneath
ACH risk analystThe analyst runs 34 third-party senders with 18,600 originators behind them and 3.2 million entries a month, and opens this one: 1,240 originators as a tree, grouped by industry and entry type. Staffing and payroll, medical and dental practices, property management, fitness and membership, online subscriptions, billing and receivables. Most branches are calm. Five carry a small chip.
Its own unauthorized return rate is 0.18 % against a 0.5 % level. That is comfortably inside, which is the whole problem.
- 02Under two minutes
Six agents read the registration, the roster and the files
The agentsThe registration agent reads the registration record and the origination agreement, and lists the Company Identifications actually sending. The roster agent reads all 1,240 rows, with no sampling, screens each name and checks the due diligence evidence on file. The returns agent measures each originator from the bank's own ACH files, and the nesting agent compares what is in the files with what is on the roster. The audit evidence agent reads the audit and the risk assessment, and the review writer turns it all into findings with their reason codes.
1,240 rows, 6 industry groups, 4 entry types: each row read, with no sampling.
- 03One click
1,240 originators, filtered to the five that need a person
ACH risk analystA dental practice has no beneficial ownership certification on file. A property manager, a fitness club and an online media company are over the unauthorized return level. One billing company is not an originator at all. A sixth finding is about the sender itself.
Status is a word as well as a color: returns over level, no due diligence on file, nested sender.
- 04The rates
Measured per originator, against the Nacha levels
Returns agentOver a rolling 60 days, the media company is at 1.12 % unauthorized on 2,144 WEB and TEL debits, and 4.29 % administrative, over both levels. The fitness club is at 0.73 % on 3,718 debits, and the property manager at 0.61 % on 6,430. The codes behind each rate are kept, and the window can be 30, 60 or 90 days.
All three of the sender's own rates are inside their levels. A sender-level report stops here.
- 05One originator
A company the bank has never met, with all of its evidence
ACH risk analystThe fitness club: its Company Identification, WEB membership dues, 1,859 entries a month, its row on the sender's roster, and the descriptor its debits carry. Screening cleared and was confirmed by the BSA Officer; the business formation document and the beneficial ownership certification are on file; 27 unauthorized returns put it over the level.
The agents screen and gather evidence, and they do not clear a hit. A named person does.
- 06The finding nobody declared
A sender hiding behind the sender
Nesting agentOne Company Identification has sent WEB and TEL debits for 230 days, 56,400 entries and $27.9 million, under the name of a billing company, and there is no row for it in the 1,240 the sender supplied. Its addenda name 37 of its own clients. Its own business is processing payments for small service businesses. The origination agreement has a clause that does not permit it.
Two clocks: 30 days after the first entry, long since missed, and 10 days from the day the bank knew.
- 07Any value
Each number opens the record it came from
ACH risk analystThe analyst clicks the roster finding and reads the search itself: the roster was searched for the Company Identification and for the billing company's name, and no row matches. The agreement clause, the audit page, the screening run, the return report and the customer due diligence index all open the same way.
Read by the agents and not changed.
- 08The paperwork
A date is not a scope
Registration and audit evidence agentsThe registration record says nested senders: no, which the files contradict. The agreement forbids them. And last year's annual rules compliance audit covered PPD and CCD entries only: WEB and TEL were not in scope. 341 originators across four industry groups send them, including all three over a return level. The request to the sender is drafted from the gaps.
The audit evidence agent does not sign off a scope gap.
- 09The decision
Analyst prepares, BSA Officer checks, committee decides
ACH risk committee chairThe chain is on the screen: prepared by the analyst that morning, screening confirmed by the BSA Officer the evening before with all 1,240 cleared, and the decision waiting for the committee. The committee chair suspends the billing company's entries pending registration with a reason code, in the chair's own words, and signs. Switched to internal audit, each of those actions is unavailable and the evidence pack still downloads.
Report-filing matters are not part of this review; they stay with the BSA Officer in the financial-crime case file.
- 10After the decision
Eight items, each with the evidence that closes it
ACH risk analyst · oversight managerSuspend the entries, register the billing company as a nested sender inside the ten-day clock, amend the origination agreement, get its own risk assessment and audit, run due diligence on its 37 companies, a 60-day rate plan for the three originators, the missing certification, and an audit scope extended to WEB and TEL. Each item names the record that closes it, and the person who raised it cannot close it alone.