SystemManufacturing Intelligence

Supplier Quality Scorecard

A supplier quality scorecard built only from lot evidence: each supplier's certificate of analysis set beside the plant's own full test of the same lot, and each lot followed into the batches that used it.

See one supplier's certificates tested screen by screen ↓
Watch with transcript →
The problem

Each full test passed the limit, and the certificate was wrong each time

Reduced testing lets the plant accept most lots of a component on the supplier's certificate plus an identity test. It is defensible only while the plant shows, at intervals, that the certificate can be relied on. In practice the periodic full test is checked against the specification rather than the certificate, so a certificate that reads one point low passes year after year.

The annual supplier review is a spreadsheet of on-time delivery, deviations and audit status, rated once. Lots the plant never tests are accepted on numbers that are not the lot's. A longer drying time in production is never traced back to the filler, and the gap surfaces at an inspection or at a client's audit of the CDMO's supplier control.

Built forSupplier quality specialistsHeads of qualityQC incoming materials analystsProcess engineers

The Problem Today

Lots pass on the supplier's certificate, and the periodic full test is checked against the limit instead of the certificate.

Rated once a year, in a sheet

  • COAs
  • LIMS tests
  • ERP lots
  • QMS events
  • A one-sided gap inside the limitResults pass, so no one compares them with the certificate
  • A rating nobody can openThe annual score rests on a spreadsheet, not on lots

The Solution

  1. Each certificate beside our labLot by lot, attribute by attribute, against method repeatability
  2. The supplier's side arguedMethod, storage and sample size answered; the agents' own slip removed
  3. Stricter testing at onceFull testing from the next lot, a deviation opened, a request in fixed fields
  4. A score from evidencePublished only after the countersignature

Built-in controls

  • Stricter testing goes first; looser waits for two people
  • No one countersigns or approves their own change
  • Supplier free text stays unread until a person opens it

What You Get

Supplier trust rests on lot evidence, and a certificate that drifts is caught before more lots are accepted on it.

  • An evidence file for each auditEach certificate beside the plant's result, the challenge and the signature
  • One ruling guards each plantAn approved rule flags the same pattern at other suppliers
  • Hundreds of suppliers, one teamReviews with no change signed in bulk after a sample
Features

Supplier quality scorecard features, from one filler's certificates to a rule

Supplier quality, QA, QC and process engineering use these screens to test whether a supplier's certificates can be relied on and to act when they cannot. They follow one microcrystalline cellulose filler on reduced testing.

demoThe CDMO, its suppliers, clients, people, lots and results are sample data.

  1. 01Certificate and our lab

    Certificate of analysis checked against our own full test, lot by lot

    • Each certificate beside our result for that lot. A gap that sits on one side shows up even while every result passes the specification, the very case a check against the limit misses.
    • Gaps measured against method repeatability. A pair turns amber only when its gap exceeds the method's own repeatability, so ordinary lab noise raises no flag.
    • Particle size, bulk density and identity alongside. The specialist sees which attribute is off, and that identity on each container cannot vouch for the rest.
  2. 02One lot

    COA verification with the supplier's certificate beside the LIMS sheet

    • Both records, as issued. The specialist checks each value against the source documents instead of a number retyped into a spreadsheet.
    • Storage and timing on the record. Manufacture, receipt and test dates sit beside the result, so time in storage is part of the evidence.
  3. 03Challenger

    The supplier's side argued before anyone relies on the finding

    • Method, storage and sample size tested. Each objection a supplier would raise is answered from the records, so the corrective action request survives the supplier's reply.
    • The agents' own retest error removed. A retest of an opened bag, first counted as a receipt test, is taken out and the mean gap recomputed.
    • Storage settled by retained samples. Where only the supplier's sealed retained samples can answer, the specialist decides to ask for them.
  4. 04Lots into batches

    Supplier lots followed into the batches that used them

    • Lot to batch, drying time and deviations. Each supplier lot is traced into its batches with their drying times, deviations and OOS results.
    • An association, with the water sum shown. The screen shows the extra moisture explains under a minute of drying, so nobody mistakes an association for a cause.
    • Confirmed by the process engineer. The link enters a supplier request only after the process engineer reads the historian record and confirms it.
  5. 05Testing level

    Reduced testing of raw materials ended at once, with a deviation opened

    • Stricter testing takes effect at once. The next lot from the supplier needs a full test the same morning, and the countersignature follows.
    • A discrepancy investigated, as EU GMP expects. Ending certificate acceptance opens a deviation that covers the lots already accepted on certificate and the batches made from them.
    • Supplier corrective action request (SCAR) in fixed fields. The supplier is asked for named tests and printouts by a due date, so the answer comes back comparable.
  6. 06Countersign

    Head of quality countersigns the change after reading reason and evidence

    • No countersigning one's own change. The specialist who ended reduced testing cannot countersign it, and the head of quality must open the reason and the evidence first.
    • Restoring reduced testing waits. Looser testing needs an accepted answer, fresh full tests on lots made after the correction, and approval from a second person.
  7. 07Scorecard

    Supplier scorecard built only from records you can open

    • Six rows, each with its source. Certificate reliability, first-time acceptance, deviations and OOS, delivery, change notices and audit each open the records behind their points.
    • Published only after the countersign. Procurement never sees a draft score; the published score freezes when the head of quality signs.
  8. 08QC intake

    Incoming lot blocked from acceptance on certificate at the QC bench

    • The change enforced at the bench. For that supplier's lots the QC analyst can only record a full test; acceptance on certificate is closed.
    • QA dispositions the lot. The analyst records results in numeric fields and signs, and the lot's disposition stays with QA.
  9. 09Learned rule

    One ruling becomes a rule at every plant when the head of quality approves

    • Rules from rulings, approved first. Nothing the agents learn applies until the head of quality approves it, and the person who made the ruling cannot approve the rule.
    • Another supplier flagged the same day. The approved rule runs across the plants and flags a starch supplier whose full tests sit above its certificates.

Production data reaches the supplier only after a process engineer confirms it

A testing change starts in supplier quality, gets the head of quality's second signature, is enforced at the QC incoming bench, and leans on process engineering for anything about batches.

Supplier quality specialists

Keep supplier files and scorecards, change testing levels and send corrective action requests

  • Certificates tested against the plant's own lab
  • Objections answered before the request goes
  • Answers in fields they can compare
Heads of quality

Approve testing levels, rules and settings, and countersign changes

  • Pairs and reasons to read before signing
  • Scores published only on their signature
  • Rules that reach other plants once approved
QC incoming materials analysts

Test identity on each container and run full tests at receipt

  • Which lots need the full panel
  • Acceptance on certificate closed when it must be
  • Results recorded in numeric fields
Process engineers

Judge whether a supplier lot shows up in batch process data

  • Lots traced to batches and drying times
  • The water sum beside the association
  • A say before production reaches the supplier

Requests go out in fixed fields, and replies are read only from them

The specialist acts on what they find; the head of quality signs second.

Certificate reader

Reads supplier certificates and the plant's LIMS results and pairs them lot by lot, attribute by attribute.

  • Decides no testing level
  • Counts no retest as a receipt test
Lot linker

Follows supplier lots into batches, drying times, deviations and OOS results.

  • Claims no cause
  • Puts production in no request before a process engineer confirms
Score builder

Builds the six score rows from cited records and proposes rules from rulings.

  • Publishes no score until it is countersigned
Challenger

Argues the supplier's side on method, storage and sample size, then tests the agents' own draft.

  • Softens no point to close it
Request writer

Builds the corrective action request from fixed fields the specialist chooses.

  • Adds no free text to an outgoing request
  • Sends nothing without a signature
Answer reader

Reads the supplier's answer from its fixed fields and attachments and compares the results with the plant's own.

  • Reads and classifies no free text
  • Accepts no answer

The agents' own first count took in a retest of a bag stored for a year

Four findings from one filler's two years of lots that an annual rating had recorded as reliable.

Certificate low on each full test

All 6 full tests read 0.9 to 1.4 points wetter than the certificate, while each result passed the 7.0% limit.

A retest counted as a receipt test

The first count of 7 pairs included a 12-month retest of an opened bag; taken out, the mean gap is 1.1 points.

Seven batches that dried longer

The two wettest lots went into 7 batches that dried 37 to 40 min against a median of 34, an association for the engineer.

The same pattern at another supplier

The approved rule flagged a starch supplier whose 6 of 6 full tests read 0.4 to 0.7 points above its certificates.

demoSample data, from the working solution.

More screens

One cellulose supplier's certificates miss by 1.1 points, another's by 0.1

Around the one filler: what the agents first concluded, how every supplier scores, and the rules the head of quality controls.

The draft, before the challengerThe first read counted 7 of 7 lots and a mean gap of 1.2, with the retest still in; it stays a draft until the challenge is settled.
Scorecards for 420 suppliersEach supplier's testing level, certificate gap, score and open items, scoped by plant and client, with a review queue of 38.
The same material from two suppliersOne cellulose supplier reads +1.1 points against the plant's lab, the other +0.1, by the same compendial method.
Each action with its reason and meaningPeople and agents, with the reason, the meaning of each signature and the session; the evidence file downloads marked signed or unsigned.
Testing rules and score weightsFull-test frequency, the not-reliable trigger, the restore gate, weights, residency and retention; the administrator proposes and the head of quality approves.

demoSample data, from the working solution.

A change notice sent late costs points, measured against the quality agreement

Supplier certificates of analysisEach lot's certificate as issued, with the values, methods and the designated person's signature.
LIMS resultsIdentity on each container and the plant's own full tests at receipt.
ERP receipts, usage and deliveriesWhich lot arrived when, whether on time, and which batches used it.
QMS deviations, OOS results and auditsQuality events on each supplier's lots and the supplier audit status.
Batch records and the process historianDrying times and process data for the batches made from each lot.
Quality agreements and change noticesWhat the supplier agreed to report, and whether each change was notified on time.

What supplier quality teams ask about a supplier quality scorecard

What is a supplier quality scorecard?

A supplier quality scorecard rates each supplier on quality evidence. Here each row is built from records you can open: the certificate of analysis beside the plant's own full test of the same lot, first-time acceptance, deviations and OOS results, delivery, change notices and audit status.

What does reduced testing of raw materials require?

A manufacturer may accept a supplier's report of analysis in place of full testing, with an identity test on each lot, only while it shows at intervals that the supplier's results can be relied on. This solution makes that check against the certificate value itself, lot by lot, instead of against the specification limit.

What happens when a certificate cannot be relied on?

The supplier quality specialist ends reduced testing at once, and a deviation opens for the certificate discrepancy. The head of quality opens the reason and the evidence, then countersigns, the score drops, and a corrective action request in fixed fields goes to the supplier.

How is the supplier's answer read?

From its fixed fields and attachments. A typed comment is held unread until the specialist opens it, an answer missing results or printouts can only be returned, and accepting an answer is the specialist's decision.

Can the agents change a testing level or publish a score?

No. They read, pair, link and draft. The specialist changes the testing level and sends requests, the head of quality signs second and approves rules and settings, and nobody approves their own change.

Which records can change a supplier's score?

Certificates, the plant's own lab results, receipts and deliveries, deviations and OOS results, audits and change notices, and no record outside them. A later result changes the draft only; the published score stays as the head of quality countersigned it until the next countersignature.

Bring one supplier you
accept on certificate.

Send two years of a supplier's certificates and your periodic full tests for the same lots, and we will pair them and show whether the certificate holds.