SystemManufacturing Intelligence

Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) Analysis

Cost of poor quality priced deviation by deviation from the time log, timesheets, lab tests, work orders and the plant schedule, on a cost basis finance and quality both sign.

Follow one deviation from cost sheet to signed ledger ↓
Watch with transcript →
The problem

Nobody prices a deviation the same way twice, so finance never signs the total

Ask what a deviation cost and each plant answers differently. One uses a flat rate, another a guess, and a held batch or a stopped granulator lands in the total as if the money had left the company. Finance cannot sign a figure built that way, and the quality council stops trusting it.

The largest losses hide in repeats. A seal that keeps failing, or a lyophilization cycle that keeps drifting, is costed one event at a time and looks cheap each time. When prevention asks for budget, it brings an opinion to a meeting where every other project brings a number.

Built forQA deviation specialistsPlant finance controllersHeads of qualityOperational excellence leads

The Problem Today

Plants price deviations by habit, so the total mixes cash with held stock and idle hours, and nobody in finance will sign it.

62%
of 163 shortage drugs had manufacturing or quality problems, FDA published

Added up by hand, event by event

  • Time logs
  • Lab tests
  • Work orders
  • Schedules
  • Held stock booked as a lossCash tied up in quarantine swells the reported total
  • Repeat failures look cheapEach event is costed alone, so a family never shows

The Solution

  1. Priced from its own recordsHours, tests, parts and stops, each line quantity times a signed rate
  2. Challenged as a CFO wouldIdle time and held stock leave the cash column, with the record cited
  3. Reviewed, then rankedFinance reviews each sheet before it reaches the ledger of cause families
  4. One basis, two ownersFinance and quality sign the rates once; the ledger re-prices on them

Built-in controls

  • Idle hours and held stock are kept out of cost
  • Preparer, reviewer and basis owners are different people
  • Batch, lab and quality system records are the sources

What You Get

Quality spending is argued like any investment, from a cost figure that finance and quality have both signed.

  • Recurring failures priced as familiesA seal that keeps failing ranks among the plant's costliest causes
  • Plants compared like for likeOne signed basis prices every plant, product and client
  • New specialists price like controllersThe challenger asks the finance questions each time
Features

Cost of poor quality features, from one deviation to a co-signed basis

A QA deviation specialist prices a granulation deviation whose investigation has just closed, and the plant finance controller decides whether the sheet counts.

demoThe CDMO, its four plants, clients, people, batches, rates and costs are sample data.

  1. 01Cost sheet

    COPQ calculation sheet: each line quantity times rate, with its source

    • Quantity times rate equals amount. Each line is laid out as a plant controller writes a working paper, so finance can check the arithmetic line by line.
    • Hours only where the record ID is. Time entries with no record ID are left out and listed, so a meeting nobody logged against the event cannot inflate it.
    • Each agent's reading on the rail. The preparer sees which records each agent linked and how sure it is before accepting any line.
  2. 02Source record

    QMS time log and timesheets opened behind each priced line

    • The record as its own system shows it. A disputed figure is settled by opening the time log, work order or lab request it came from.
    • Each open written to the trail. Each open is kept on the trail, so a reviewer's signature shows which records stood behind it.
  3. 03Idle capacity

    Idle capacity separated from cost using the plant's own schedule

    • Down hours checked against orders. Equipment time with no order waiting stays in hours, so a stopped machine is no longer reported as money lost.
    • Planned no-order time left out. Hours the schedule had already left empty are dropped, which keeps the idle figure honest for the plant head.
  4. 04CFO challenger

    A challenger asks the CFO's questions of every line over the threshold

    • Cash, absorbed, idle or tied up. Each large line is tested for which of the four it really is, with the record that decides it.
    • Errors in the agents' draft caught. A held batch the draft booked as a lost shipment is caught from the client's open order before anyone signs.
    • Counted twice, or caused by this event. The challenger asks whether the client-notice hours also sit inside the investigation hours, and the record IDs in the time log settle it.
  5. 05Four columns

    Cost of poor quality as cash plus absorbed labor, with the rest apart

    • Two columns make the cost. Cash and absorbed labor add up to the figure, while idle hours and held stock are shown beside it and left out of the sum.
    • An undecided disposition shown as two branches. While the QA disposition lead decides a held batch, both outcomes are visible and neither is booked.
  6. 06Ledger

    COPQ analysis by cause family for one plant, reviewed sheets only

    • Only reviewed sheets count. A sheet reaches the ledger after the finance controller has opened its records and reviewed it under their own sign-in.
    • Ranked by family, product, line or plant. A seal that failed twice shows as one family, so a repeat cause stands next to the plant's largest losses.
    • Scoped to a plant or a client. Each client's products can be read on their own, which gives a business review evidence behind every figure.
  7. 07What-if

    Prevention what-if weighing a CAPA's spend against its failure cost

    • Assumptions anyone can change. The operational excellence lead edits impeller hours, intervals and kit price, and each change is logged with its source.
    • Cash and absorbed shown apart. The plan's case rests on the write-off risk where its cash alone would not carry it, and the screen says so.
    • A rehearsal, kept from becoming a forecast. The planner shows its sums and commits nothing, and only the head of operations approves the spend.
  8. 08Cost basis

    Loaded labor rates and standard costs in one co-signed cost basis

    • Signed by finance and quality. One rate card every plant uses, so a plant's figure means the same thing at the quality council as in the budget.
    • The drafter cannot sign it. The operational excellence lead who drafted the new version proposes it, and the two owners sign.
    • The trailing year restated. Months priced on older rates are restated at the rates in force, so plants and months compare like for like.
  9. 09All plants

    Prevention, appraisal and failure costs for all plants on one basis

    • Prevention, appraisal, internal and external failure. The four-part model the quality council already knows, with prevention and appraisal taken from cost centers.
    • Catch-all rows left unranked. Costs that belong to no single cause sit at the bottom, below the families they would otherwise crowd out.

Finance co-owns the rates quality prices with, so neither moves them alone

The person who prices a sheet never reviews it, and whoever drafts the rates never signs them.

QA deviation specialists

Price each closed deviation and answer the challenger's points

  • Hours and costs gathered from the records
  • The finance questions asked before review
  • A queue with a clock on each event
Plant finance controllers

Review each priced sheet and co-own the cost basis

  • Working papers they can check line by line
  • Held stock and idle hours kept out of cost
  • One basis for every plant
Heads of quality

Co-own the basis and sign the quality council pack

  • Recurring failures ranked by what they cost
  • A pack with every figure sourced
  • Cost of poor quality for each product's annual review
Operational excellence leads

Build what-ifs and propose prevention spend

  • A CAPA's cost against the failure it removes
  • Assumptions shown with where each comes from
  • Families to aim prevention at
More screens

A seal failure that ended in a rejected batch ranks its family third

Around the cost sheet: the family behind a recurring cause, the queue of events still to price, what goes to the quality council, the rules learned from rulings and the audit trail.

A recurring cause, event by eventGranulator impeller seal wear: two deviations on one granulator, the earlier one ending with a rejected batch, which is why the family ranks third.
Each event on its own clock16 events to price and 30 to review across all four plants, each with a price-by or review-by date, 4 past their clock.
What the quality council and the product review receiveThe council pack lists open outcomes without booking them and leaves counsel's notes out; the product's section supports management review under ICH Q10.
Rulings that become pricing rulesHours without a record ID left out is active; idle equipment time and held stock as working capital wait for a basis owner who did not make the ruling.
The re-pricing on the trailOpens, sign-ins, the review, the fold into the ledger and both basis signatures, each with its reason and the meaning of the signature.

demoSample data, from the working solution.

The finance controller's review is the only door into the ledger

QA deviation specialist
Sees
The draft sheet, the challenger's points and the records behind each line
Signs
Accepts or keeps each challenged line, then sends the sheet for review
Plant finance controller
Sees
The time log and each line's quantity, column and source
Signs
Reviews the sheet, or sends it back with a code that names what to fix
Head of quality
Sees
The new rates against the old, and what re-pricing changes
Signs
Co-signs the cost basis, approves learned rules and signs the council pack
Head of operations
Sees
The what-if with its assumptions and both columns of the plan
Signs
Approves or sends back the prevention spend

A held batch stays off the cost line until the disposition lead signs

Release or rejection of a held batchThe QA disposition lead decides in the quality system; the sheet reads that signed decision when it exists and books nothing before it.
Which column a challenged line belongs inThe challenger argues; the preparer accepts or keeps the line, and the reviewer can send it back.
Whether a sheet countsOnly the finance controller's review folds it into the ledger, and a later reopen takes it out again.
The rates every plant prices withBoth basis owners, finance and quality, sign it; until both have, totals stay on the old one.
Prevention spendThe head of operations approves it; an approved plan shows as not yet spent.

The plant schedule decides whether a stopped granulator cost anything

QMS deviation and investigation recordsThe event, its investigation time log, containment actions and client notices.
Time and attendanceTimesheet hours by role, coded to the event's record IDs, and overtime.
LIMS test requestsExtra tests with their price list, split into reagents and analysts' time.
CMMS work ordersParts, kits and technicians' hours on the equipment the event touched.
Plant scheduleWhich orders were planned on the equipment, and whether any waited.
ERP standard costs, holds and cost centersHeld stock at standard cost, and prevention and appraisal spend.
Client portal order fieldsWhether a client's order is open, delayed or canceled.

What finance and quality ask about the cost of poor quality

What is the cost of poor quality?

The cost of poor quality is what failures cost a plant: deviations, rework, rejects, write-offs and client send-backs. Here it is cash plus absorbed labor, priced event by event from the records each one left, with idle hours and held stock shown beside it and kept out of the total.

How is COPQ calculated for a deviation?

Each line is a quantity from a record times a rate from the signed cost basis: investigation hours from the time log and timesheets, tests from the lab, parts and contractor time from the work order. A challenger then checks which lines are really cash.

Is a held batch part of the cost of poor quality?

Only once its disposition is signed. Until then it is working capital at standard cost, and the sheet shows what a release and a rejection would each add, so the quality council sees the exposure without booking it.

Why are idle equipment hours kept apart?

A machine with no order waiting loses no sale, and crew and depreciation are paid either way. Idle time is kept in hours, and lost contribution is counted only where the schedule shows an order waited.

Does it follow the prevention, appraisal and failure model?

Yes. Failure costs are priced event by event as internal or external failure, while prevention and appraisal come from cost centers, so the ledger reads in the model quality councils already use.

Can a client see the cost of poor quality on its own products?

The ledger can be scoped to one client's products, with the sheet and records behind each figure, so a CDMO can bring evidence to a client business review.

What counts as external failure?

Client batch-record send-backs, a shipment returned for a mismatch in its aggregation file, and late-delivery credits under supply agreements. They sit in their own column of the ledger, beside internal failure.

Send us one deviation
and its time log.

Send a closed deviation with its timesheets, tests and work orders, and we will price it line by line on your own rates.