- Before
- “I can tell you who was told. I can't tell you, today, that every mailbox is still on hold.”
- Now
- Opens one grid per hold with every source checked at 07:00, the people who haven't acknowledged, and the leavers already caught.
One hold, from the demand letter to a signed release
Kessler Instruments says two of its former engineers, hired by Northbay Components, a Kestrel & Vane company, brought its pressure-sensor designs into the PX-400 programme. Its lawyers' letter arrives on Monday 21 September. Here is how the hold runs, screen by screen, in the working solution.
- 01Wednesday morning
Every custodian, every system, on one grid
Rhea Castellano · eDiscovery managerRhea runs 31 active holds for the group. Hold HLD-2026-0147 opens as a grid: 24 custodians down the side, nine systems across — mailbox, OneDrive, Teams, Slack, laptop, phone, Salesforce, PLM vault, HR file. This morning 130 of 138 sources are preserved and verified, 21 of 24 custodians have acknowledged, and one row is red: Julia Moreno, who leaves on 16 October.
“Four disposals were scheduled on her data. The agent stopped each one on its own, under rule W-1, and needs two decisions.”
- 02Mon 21 Sep, 08:47
The letter dates the duty
Intake agentThe intake agent reads Albright Fenn LLP's four-page letter and classifies it as a demand letter that threatens suit: “Kessler intends to commence proceedings.” It dates the duty to preserve from receipt, proposes the scope — Kessler, PX-400, PX-200 and the two hires, from 1 January 2023 — and sets the clock to issue by Tuesday 17:00. The hold goes out at 10:14 on Tuesday, 25 hours after the letter.
Search and collection stay locked until the hold is issued.
- 03The same day
A reason for every custodian
Scoping agentFrom the letter, the complaint, the org chart and message counts, the scoping agent proposes 25 people, each with the reason and a confidence: Elena Petrov ran the Kessler supply negotiations, with 412 messages to kessler-instruments.com. Sofia Grant approves 21, removes three with a reason each, and keeps a former employee's archived mailbox without a notice. It counts messages only; no content is read before the hold.
The scoping agent never adds or removes a custodian — counsel decides.
- 04Tue 22 Sep, 10:14
A notice people understand, in their language
Notice agentNotice v2 goes out in English, German and Spanish, in plain words: what this is, what to keep, what not to do, what IT has already done. The notice agent reminds on day 3 and day 7, escalates to the manager on day 10 and re-notices every 90 days. On this hold the median time to acknowledge is 1.1 hours; Diego Fuentes, after three reminders, has been escalated twice to Marcus Webb.
The notice agent never edits an approved notice; a new version goes to counsel.
- 05As answers come back
Answers that change the scope
Interview agentEach custodian answers six questions when they acknowledge. Elena Petrov names Wen Liu, who ran the Kessler price comparisons; Wen Liu is added on 29 September. Hannah Brooks mentions a WhatsApp group, “PX400 bench”, with a contractor from Pellow Engineering. Arjun Mehta has a USB drive from his time at Kessler. Each answer becomes a proposal for Sofia, quoted word for word.
The interview agent never adds a source or a person itself.
- 06Every morning, 07:00
Every hold checked, not assumed
Preservation agentThe preservation agent placed holds the way each system supports them — litigation and case holds in Microsoft 365, Slack's legal hold, reimage blocks on laptops, wipe blocks on phones, retention locks in the PLM vault. Each morning it confirms every one is present: 2,974 checks since 22 September. Today the PLM vault timed out once and passed on retry at 07:10.
“A source counts as preserved only if it passed in the last 24 hours.”
- 07Wed 14 Oct, 09:12
A key engineer resigns — and four disposals are already scheduled
Watch agentThe HR system records Julia Moreno's resignation, last day Friday. The watch agent matches her to the hold — she is named in the complaint — and finds what IT already has queued: ticket RITM-48213 to reimage laptop KV-LT-20931 on Friday at 17:00, an exit wipe of her phone, mailbox and OneDrive deletion 30 days after leaving, and Slack deactivation. By 09:14 the ticket is on hold, the wipe blocked, both deletions paused and Slack confirmed to keep her messages.
The watch agent may only stop a disposal. It never deletes, releases or drops a custodian.
- 0809:31
Counsel keeps her in the hold and approves the image
Sofia Grant · Senior litigation counselThe agent hands Sofia the two decisions it may not make, with the HR event, the ticket, the complaint paragraphs and its confidence of 0.98. She picks the reason code “Key custodian — keep after departure”, ticks that the decision is hers and types her name. The mailbox is kept as an inactive mailbox under hold, and Owen Mbeki images the laptop remotely: 238 GB, SHA-256 verified.
“I have read the evidence and this decision is mine.”
- 09After the stipulation
Release only what no other hold needs
Release agentA joint stipulation filed on 9 October withdraws the PX-200 claims. The release agent proposes releasing the six PX-200 custodians and checks their 34 sources against 30 other open holds. Four of Marta Kowalski's — mailbox, OneDrive, Teams and Salesforce — are still needed by the Alder Systems warranty claim, so they stay held. Sofia signs; retention resumes on 30 sources, and each release notice says what stays held.
A full release stays closed until a dismissal, settlement or judgment is on the docket.
- 10Ready for a motion
The reasonable-steps record, built as the hold ran
Rhea Castellano · eDiscovery managerThe defensibility record has every step with its time and source: letter to hold in 25 hours, 24 of 24 custodians told in writing, 2,974 daily checks with 3 exceptions cured, 0 sources lost, and the release with its authority. A draft preservation declaration is written from the log for Sofia to edit; nothing is filed until she approves it.
Every export is logged with who took it and why.