- Sees
- Each dyke's pins, the repeat chains and the instruments
- Signs
- The inspector's closures, and raises repeats with a funded action
A tailings dam safety finding that seven yearly reports kept raising
A dam inspector has proposed closing a foundation pressure finding on Dyke 3, 58 m high and active. Here is what the responsible engineer and the accountable executive see before anyone signs it.
demoThe mine, its dykes, its engineers and all the readings are sample data.
- 01Morning
23 open findings drawn where they sit on Dyke 3
Responsible tailings facility engineerThe dyke is drawn to its own shape: crest, beach and pond, benches, toe berm and drain, the foundation layers and the instruments. Each open finding is a pin at its zone, bigger for each year it has stayed open, ringed when it repeats. At the top of his list, an inspector's closure that the evidence check says does not answer what was asked.
- 02Morning
Four serious findings in the foundation, one of them open eight years
Responsible tailings facility engineerHe narrows the drawing to the foundation. Four open, all serious: an inclinometer showing movement at the top of the weak clay layer, a replacement still outstanding, the board asking about strength tests, and foundation pressure at the piezometer under the toe berm, still rising. That last pin sits beside its instrument, labeled at 298.2 m, yellow.
- 03Morning
Up 3.1 m in October readings since 2019, past the model and past yellow
Responsible tailings facility engineerThe trend lays every October reading against the engineer of record's levels: the 297.5 m the stability model assumed, yellow at 298.0, red at 298.5, and the berm surface at 298.6. This year's 298.2 m is 138.3 kPa at the tip. The levels come from the operations manual; agents do not set or move them.
- 04Late morning
Seven engineer of record reports, four not logged, two closed wrongly
Responsible tailings facility engineerThe repeat finder matches by place and meaning rather than wording. It lays out each year's sentence beside the piezometer and inclinometer for that year and how the sentence was logged. Four were not logged. One was closed when monthly reads started, another as to be reviewed next year. The newest asks for a stability reassessment of the section.
- 05Late morning
A confirmed reading is not a stability reassessment
Responsible tailings facility engineerThe inspector's closure says the logger and cable were checked and a manual dip read the same level. Her evidence fails the check: it proves the reading is real, which makes the reassessment more urgent. A second hold comes from the trigger rule, since no closure can be signed while the piezometer is above yellow.
- 06Before noon
He stops the closure and raises a $263,000 action
Responsible tailings facility engineerHe stops the inspector's closure with a reason she will read in her own queue, then raises the finding to the accountable executive by name. The funded action he wrote: a reassessment by the engineer of record, two new foundation piezometers, daily review of the logger data by him, and Pond 3 held at or below 346.6 m until the reassessment is accepted.
- 07Same day
Signing stays off until she opens the passages and the trends
Accountable executiveThe raise lands on her desk with a clock of 10 working days. She reads why it came: the finding sits in seven reports and was closed twice without the work it asked for. The sign button reads 0 of 2 opened. She can also send it back, with a reason, if the plan is weak.
- 08Same day
She reads each year's sentence before she funds the work
Accountable executiveThe seven passages open as one table: what each report said, how it was logged, and the piezometer and inclinometer readings that year, with how closely the repeat finder matched each one. She then opens the two trends. Nothing she signs rests on a summary she did not read.
- 09After signing
Her signature on the trail, after each item she opened
Internal auditorIn order on the trail: the executive opened the seven passages, then the trends, then signed the funded action and the Pond 3 hold. The escalation router told the responsible engineer and the engineer of record when the reassessment is due. Until that reassessment is accepted, the finding itself stays open.