WorkflowInvestment Risk Management

Independent Price Verification

Independent price verification that explains or challenges every outlier before the NAV is struck

See one case, screen by screen ↓
Watch with transcript →

Built forPricing analystsValuation managersHeads of valuationFund controllersExternal auditors

The Problem Today

Analysts read broker emails by eye and chase vendors by hand, so a wrong price can reach the NAV unchallenged.

3.5 h
of an analyst's afternoon before the lock, by hand our estimate

Read and retyped by hand

  • Vendor file
  • Broker runs
  • Trades
  • News
  • Most flags are the marketFixed tolerance bands flag moves the whole market made
  • Overrides on a printoutThe evidence is rebuilt by hand when the auditor asks

The Solution

  1. Each quote read and mappedBroker runs from email, PDFs and free text, in the dealer's language
  2. Market moves explainedEach price tested against its dealer spread; each move given its reason
  3. The vendor challengedDrafted with dealer quotes and the trade, sent on the analyst's yes
  4. A second person checksThe analyst decides with a reason code; moves over two points go up

Built-in controls

  • Only the fund controller locks prices
  • Agents never accept or edit a price
  • Each quote and decision sealed in a hash chain

What You Get

More wrong prices are challenged before the NAV is struck, and each changed price carries evidence an auditor can test.

51 min
of hands-on time before the lock, down from 3.5 hours our estimate
  • Vendor replies tracked to the lockFollowed up, then escalated before the price lock
  • Any dealer's languageRuns in other languages read beside the English
  • Vendor oversight, countedEach challenge tallied for the monthly oversight report
In short

What is Independent Price Verification?

Independent price verification (IPV) is the daily check that a fund's prices are right: each evaluated price is tested against independent evidence (a second vendor, dealer quotes, reported trades), and a price that does not hold up is challenged with the vendor or overridden with a second person's check. Independent Price Verification from Botminds runs that process with six agents that read each quote, explain or flag each move and run the vendor challenges, while the pricing analyst decides and a second person checks.

AI in asset management: a buyer's guide to agentic AI for investment managers →

Updated

The problem

Independent price checks that run out of time before the lock

Independent price verification is a race against the clock. A fund complex prices tens of thousands of securities each evening, and the pricing team has two to three hours between the vendor files and the NAV to find the wrong prices. Static tolerances flag hundreds of exceptions a day, and most of them are moves the whole market made. Broker runs arrive in the shared pricing mailbox as free text, tables, PDFs and spreadsheets, some not in English, and analysts read them by eye and retype the levels.

The fixes are just as manual. Vendor price challenges are typed into portals and chased by email, an override carries a comment and a signature on a printout, and a portfolio manager's color can end up as the price. At month end someone counts challenges in a spreadsheet for the board. SEC Rule 2a-5 asks the valuation designee for a process for initiating price challenges and named override authority, and in May 2026 the Monetary Authority of Singapore found that managers challenged third-party prices too weakly and documented exceptions poorly.

estimated10–30%of quotes challenged each month at a typical hedge fund, mostly by email and spreadsheet
estimated75%+of static-tolerance challenges avoidable on volatile days when the market explains the move (vendor backtest)
Where a pricing analyst's afternoon goes, in hoursestimated
By hand3.5 hours
With the solution0.9 hours
  • Reading broker runs and retyping levels1 → 0.1 h
  • Working static-tolerance exceptions the market explains1 → 0.3 h
  • Drafting, sending and chasing vendor challenges0.8 → 0.2 h
  • Overrides and the second person's check0.5 → 0.3 h
  • Gathering the evidence for the record0.3 → 0.1 h

Estimated split of the hours between the vendor files and the US price lock, by hand and with the solution.

How it works

Price verification from the vendor file to the regional price lock

What comes in
Prices and quotes inThe evening's prices · vendor files, broker runs from email, trades, issuer news
Agents at work
Quote agentany language, mapped
Then
Outlier agentspread and tolerance
Market context agentexplains the move
Then
Challenge agentvendor, against the clock
Then
Checker agentre-tests every decision
Evidence agent
A person decides
Pricing analyst, Valuation Manager, Fund Controllerdecide, check, lock
What comes out
Outliers explained or challenged
Prices locked on time
Vendor report and audit packs
One case, step by step

Independent price verification on one bond in the hour before the lock

A Wednesday, 4:06 p.m. ET, at a fund complex that prices tens of thousands of securities a night. The US price lock is at 5:30 p.m. Pricing vendor A has one issuer's 6.500% senior notes, held by four funds at $84.0M par, at 101.80, while three dealers bid 99.10 to 99.60. Here is what happens next, screen by screen, in the working solution.

A worked example on sample data. Names, IDs and figures on the screens and in this section come from the demo.

  1. 014:06 p.m.

    What needs the analyst before the lock, on one screen

    Pricing analyst

    The analyst's home shows four numbers: the day's prices tested, 618 exceptions with 471 explained by the market, 147 that need a person (129 still open, 32 of them the analyst's), and 84 minutes to the US lock. The Asia and Europe locks are already done. Under “Needs you” are seven items, most urgent first, each with one button, and a box to ask the agents about any price, fund or vendor.

    “6.5% senior notes · vendor A revised 101.80 → 99.40 … move −2.40 needs the Valuation Manager after you.”

  2. 02The quote strips

    Each quote on one line, outliers first

    Pricing analyst

    Each security is one strip: each quote a dot, the dealer spread shaded, the fund price a bold bar. Strips where the fund price sits outside the spread rise to the top, 101 of them today. The 6.5% notes are first, 2.45 points above the dealer median against a 1.00-point tolerance, and the right-hand column shows the challenge: sent to vendor A at 3:12 p.m., revised to 99.40 at 4:05 p.m. A 5.875% bond has been with vendor A for 35 minutes, and a challenge on a 6.125% energy bond is drafted, waiting for the analyst.

    All quotes on one line, so the analyst can tell in a second whether the vendor is wrong.

  3. 03Since midnight

    Broker runs read from email, in the dealer's own language

    Quote agent

    The Quote agent has read 1,312 broker runs from 46 dealers and six vendor files into 16,904 quotes, 16,890 of them mapped to the security master. One overseas dealer's 3:02 a.m. run arrives as free text in its own language; the screen shows it beside the English reading and the quote taken from it, a 0.85% yen bond at 97.95 bid, 96% confidence. Free text like “99-11 / 99-19”, PDF attachments and spreadsheets are read the same way.

    Below 95% parse or 98% mapping confidence the Quote agent hands the quote to the analyst. It does not create a price.

  4. 042:31 p.m.

    The vendor is wrong on the 6.5% notes, and the market says why

    Outlier agent

    The case opens as a conversation with the agents beside the big strip. Three dealers bid the bond at 99.10, 99.35 and 99.60; $2.0M traded at 99.25; vendor B is at 99.55. The Outlier agent finds vendor A's 101.80 2.45 points above the 99.35 dealer median and ties the gap to the issuer's release: it cut its full-year adjusted EBITDA guidance to $0.94B from $1.12B after the close. Each number carries a citation that opens its source: the release, the trade report, each dealer's email.

    “The market does not explain it: high yield fell only 0.30 today … I recommend challenging vendor A.”

  5. 053:12 to 4:05 p.m.

    Challenged with the evidence, revised in 53 minutes

    Challenge agent · Pricing analyst

    At 3:09 p.m. the Challenge agent drafted the challenge to vendor A with three broker runs, the trade and the issuer release attached, asking for 99.35. The analyst answered “Send it.” The agent tracked the reply against the 60-minute rule, followed up at 3:57 p.m., and at 4:05 p.m. vendor A revised to 99.40: “Evaluator incorporated post-earnings dealer color and the 11:52 a.m. trade.” Before approving, the analyst asks the agents what holding the prior price would mean.

    “Holding the prior price 101.65 needs reason HD-01 and the Valuation Manager's approval … I would not recommend it while the vendor has answered before the lock.”

  6. 064:06 p.m.

    Approved with a reason, then re-tested by the Checker agent

    Pricing analyst · Checker agent

    The analyst approves the revised price with reason AP-02, “Vendor revised after challenge.” The Checker agent re-tests it against the pricing policy: inside the dealer spread, three independent quotes, the reason fits, the analyst as maker. The move is −2.40 points, above two, so it goes to the Valuation Manager. Across the four funds the market value falls $2,016,000; in the high yield bond fund it falls $1,164,000, 1.8 bp of its NAV.

    The Checker agent cannot approve or check. It can only pass an item to a person or return it with a reason.

  7. 07Bulk review

    390 moves the market explains, accepted in one step

    Pricing analyst · Outlier agent

    Most pricing exceptions are the market moving rather than the vendor being wrong. The Exceptions screen holds 390 US moves that sit inside their dealer spread, each with the agent's reason, its sources and a confidence. One issuer's 7.25% bond, for example, fell after a material-fact notice in the issuer's own language cut its allowed revenue 11% from next year. Before acceptance the Checker agent re-tests a 5% random sample, and the analyst accepts the set in one step with reason EX-01.

    Explained moves are proposed for acceptance; the agents do not accept a price on their own.

  8. 08Next on the list

    A vendor price challenge drafted, waiting for the analyst's yes

    Challenge agent

    A 6.125% energy bond: vendor B at 92.60 against three dealers at 90.75 to 91.30. The Challenge agent has drafted a challenge to vendor B's challenge channel (“HY energy fell 0.9 points today as crude dropped 3.1%; vendor B moved only 0.35. Please review and reply before 5:00 p.m. ET.”) with three dealers' quotes attached and 91.10, the dealer median, as the level asked. The analyst can edit the message, then send.

    The Challenge agent does not send without the analyst and does not edit a price.

  9. 09Second check

    Maker-checker on each changed price

    Valuation Manager

    The Valuation Manager's sign-off queue holds 44 items to check, with 21 escalations. The 6.5% notes are at the top (approved by the analyst, 101.80 to 99.40, −2.40, above two) with the Checker agent's re-test beside them: inside spread, passes. Kept vendor prices that sit outside the spread show “reason needed”. The manager checks with CK-01 or returns an item with a reason, and cannot check an item they made.

    The manager does not redo the work, only checks the evidence and the reason.

  10. 105:30 p.m. lock

    The lock shows what still blocks it

    Fund Controller

    The Asia lock closed at 5:00 a.m. ET and the Europe lock at 12:30 p.m., both released to the portfolio accounting platform and the fund administrator. For the US lock, the screen lists what still blocks it: 494 items (390 explained moves to accept, 70 decisions, 34 checks). The controller locks and releases when they clear; any price unresolved at 5:30 p.m. holds its prior-day value with the Valuation Manager's approval.

    “The Fund Controller cannot change a price, only lock and release.”

Who it’s for

Analyst, manager, controller, designee and auditor on one pricing day

The same pricing day, seen by five of the people who carry it: what it looked like by hand, and what it looks like now.

Pricing analyst
Covers US high yield, loans and emerging-market corporates
Before
Reads broker runs by eye, retypes levels and chases vendors by email between the 2 p.m. files and the 5:30 p.m. lock.
Now
Opens each outlier already explained or challenged, all quotes on one line; says yes to the challenge and decides with a reason code.
Valuation manager
The checker on changed prices
Before
Checks overrides against a signed printout and has to rebuild the evidence behind each one.
Now
Gets each override and each move above two points with the Checker agent's re-test, and checks the evidence and the reason, though not on their own work.
Fund controller
Locks and releases the prices
Before
Wants a clean lock at 5:30 and nothing that changes after it, without knowing until late what is still open.
Now
Sees exactly what blocks the lock, region by region, and releases the prices to the accounting platform and the fund administrator.
Head of valuation
Chairs the valuation designee
Before
Has challenges counted in spreadsheets at month end to evaluate the pricing services under Rule 2a-5.
Now
Signs the monthly pricing-service oversight report the Evidence agent drafts, with a citation behind each number, and approves each settings change.
External auditor
Tests prices and overrides; read-only
Before
Asks for spreadsheets and emails to test month-end prices and overrides back to their evidence.
Now
Reads each override, who made it, who checked it and the quote it rests on, and exports a watermarked pack.
The agents

The IPV process split across quote, outlier, challenge and checker agents

The analyst decides each price after six agents read the quotes, explain or flag each move, run the vendor challenges and re-test the decision; a second person checks.

Quote agent

Reads each vendor file and each broker run in the pricing mailbox (tables, free text, PDFs and spreadsheets, in any language) and maps each quote to the security master, flagging the quotes it cannot map.

  • Below 95% parse or 98% mapping confidence, the quote goes to the analyst
  • Never creates a price; a portfolio manager's quote is evidence only
Outlier agent

Tests each fund price against its quotes and the fund's tolerance policy, static and dynamic, and explains moves by sector, rates, trades and issuer news.

  • Proposes accept or challenge; never accepts a price on its own
  • Cites every reason
Market context agent

Reads issuer news, notices and filings in their own language and links them to price moves, quoting the original beside the English.

  • Cites the passage
  • Never infers a price from news alone
Challenge agent

Drafts the challenge to the pricing vendor with the dealer evidence attached and the dealer median as the level asked, sends it when the analyst says yes, tracks the reply against the 60-minute rule and the lock, follows up and escalates.

  • Never sends without the analyst
  • Never edits a price
Checker agent

Re-tests each approval and override against the pricing policy (evidence present, inside the spread, reason valid, segregation of duties) and sends moves above two points to the Valuation Manager.

  • Cannot approve or check
  • Can only pass an item to a person or return it with a reason
Evidence agent

Seals each quote, decision and setting change in a hash chain, builds auditor and regulator packs, counts each challenge and drafts the monthly vendor report.

  • Append-only; drafts only
  • Packs are watermarked
Pricing analyst, Valuation Manager, Fund Controller, auditor

Maker, checker, lock, evidence.

Ask in plain words

Any price, quote or vendor challenge, explained with its sources

Ask about any price, quote, challenge, fund or vendor, or say what to do. Each answer carries its citations, and no price changes without the analyst's approval.

Why are the 6.5% notes an outlier?

Vendor A priced them at 101.80; three dealers bid 99.10 to 99.60 and $2.0M traded at 99.25. The issuer cut its full-year EBITDA guidance to $0.94B. The vendor revised to 99.40 at 4:05 p.m.

Which challenges could miss the price lock?

21 challenges are with a vendor. The two to watch: a 5.875% bond, 35 minutes with vendor A, and the 0.85% yen bond, 26 minutes with vendor B. At 5:00 p.m. I escalate anything unanswered to the Valuation Manager.

Show stale prices

40 prices are stale today, among them the 0.85% yen bond, unchanged six days while the yen curve moved 7 bp, and a 5% bond at five days. Policy sets the stale rule by asset class.

What if I hold the prior price?

Holding the prior price 101.65 needs reason HD-01 and the Valuation Manager's approval. It would sit +2.30 from the dealer median. I would not recommend it while the vendor has answered before the lock.

The screens

Quote strips, the vendor challenge and the price lock

From the working solution, on its sample data. Pick one to see it large.

TodayThe pricing analyst's home: prices tested, exceptions, what needs a person, minutes to the price lock, and the next decision with one button each.
Quote stripsEach security's vendor prices, broker quotes and trades on one strip, the dealer spread shaded, outliers first, with each vendor price challenge and the minutes to the lock.
Broker quotes from emailA broker run in the dealer's own language, from the pricing mailbox, beside its English reading, and the quotes taken from it with their confidence.
One security, worked with the agentsAll quotes on one line, the agents' explanation with citations, and the decision panel with the fund impact.
Ask before you decideThe vendor's revised price in the conversation, and the agents' answer on what holding the prior price would mean.
Approved, re-tested, routedThe approval with its reason code, the Checker agent's re-test against the pricing policy and the sign-off chain to the Valuation Manager.
Pricing exceptions the market explainsMoves inside their dealer spread, each with its reason, sources and confidence, ready for bulk acceptance after a sample re-test.
A vendor price challenge, draftedThe challenge to the pricing vendor with the dealer quotes attached and the level asked, sent only when the analyst says yes.
Maker-checker sign-offEach changed price and kept vendor price waiting for a second person, moves above two points flagged, with the Checker agent's re-test.
The price lockLocks by region, what still blocks the US lock, and the rule for prices unresolved at the lock.
Vendor challenge statisticsChallenges, revised rate and reply times by vendor and asset class, and the Rule 2a-5 pricing-service oversight report drafted for the valuation designee.
Audit trailEach quote, challenge, decision and setting change: who, what, when, the evidence and its seal, with CSV and regulator pack export.
Tolerance policyPricing tolerance checks by asset class (day over day, against the dealer median, escalation and stale days), with dynamic bands and today's exceptions.
Governance

Two-person checks and sealed records in independent price verification

Each quote and reason cites its sourceEach quote, explanation and decision links to where it came from: the vendor file line, the broker's email, the reported trade, the issuer's passage in its original language, beside the English.
Two people on each changed priceThe IPV valuation control rests on two people: the pricing analyst decides and a second person checks. Moves above two points always go to the Valuation Manager, above five points to the Head of Valuation. Nobody checks their own work, and a portfolio manager's quote is evidence and does not become a price.
Agents propose; people decideThe agents do not accept a price, send a challenge unseen or edit a price. They read, explain, draft and re-test; the analyst approves, keeps, overrides or holds.
A reason code on each decisionApprove (AP-01 to AP-03), keep (KP-01, KP-02), override (OV-01 broker evidence more current to OV-04 corporate action not reflected), hold (HD-01, HD-02) and check (CK-01, CK-02), each with its evidence.
A lock that holdsOnly the Fund Controller locks and releases prices, and cannot change one. A price unresolved at the lock holds its prior-day value with the Valuation Manager's approval and is reviewed again the next day.
A sealed record, kept seven yearsEach quote, challenge, decision and setting change is on an append-only, hash-chained audit trail kept 7 years (Rule 31a-4 asks for six). Auditor and regulator packs are watermarked, and policy, agents and thresholds are versioned.
Configuration

Tolerances, challenge rules and price locks from the pricing policy

Pricing tolerances, challenge rules, locks and retention are settings. Changes are proposed by the administrator and take effect when the Head of Valuation approves.

SettingDefaultChoose from
HY corporates tolerance (Pricing Policy v4.3 §3)1.00 pt day over day · 1.00 against the dealer median · escalate above 2.00 · stale after 3 daysSet per asset class, from US Treasuries (0.25 · 0.15) to listed equities (10%), with the effect on today's exceptions shown before you propose
Dynamic bandsOn, capped at twice staticOn · off
Challenge whenOutside the dealer spread by more than the tolerance, with at least three independent quotesPolicy §4.2, versioned
Vendor reply60 minutes · follow-up at 45 · escalate to the Valuation Manager 30 minutes before the lockPolicy §4.5, versioned
Price locksUS 5:30 p.m. ET · Europe and Asia at their own local cut-offsSet per region
EscalationAbove 2 points to the Valuation Manager; above 5 points or Level 3 to the Head of Valuation and the valuation committeePolicy §5.4
Source hierarchy, HY corporatesPricing vendor A → pricing vendor B → dealer median (at least 3) → hold priorOrdered per asset class
Data and retention7 years · each fund's records kept in its own regionResidency, retention and entitlements by fund
Connections

Pricing vendors, broker email, market data and the accounting platform

Pricing vendorsevaluated pricing from two pricing vendors and the loan pricing vendor, and their challenge channels
Broker emailthe shared pricing mailbox: runs as tables, free text, PDFs and spreadsheets, in any language
Market datareported trades, curves and sector moves
Issuer filings and newsreleases, notices and filings in their original languages
Pricing system and security masterfund prices read, approved prices written, quotes mapped to each holding
Accounting platform and fund administratorlocked prices released for the NAV
What it changes

Price verification results: outliers challenged, overrides checked

Each figure carries its label: a target the solution is built to, an estimate, a typical published result, or a proven one.

target
100%
of exceptions explained, challenged or held with an approved reason before the price lock
every exception
not a sample
target
2people
on every changed price and override, with its evidence, kept 7 years (Rule 2a-5 names override authority)
estimated
75%+
of static-tolerance challenges avoidable on volatile days when the market explains the move (vendor backtest)
Static tolerancesevery breach challenged
Moves explainedchallenge only the outliers

“demo” = seen in the working solution, on its sample pricing day · “target” = the design goal, measured in the live solution · “estimated” = our estimate (3.5 hours of an analyst's afternoon by hand and 51 minutes with the solution: the sums of the estimated split of hours in the chart above), and two vendor figures: a pricing-software vendor on 10% to 30% of quotes challenged a month at a typical hedge fund; a market-data vendor's dynamic-tolerance backtest on volatile 2020 days, over 75% of static-tolerance challenges avoidable. Regulation named as context: SEC Rule 2a-5 (2020; compliance from September 8, 2022), Rule 31a-4, and the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) information paper on valuation practices (May 29, 2026). Pricing vendors are shown unnamed. Names on the screens are sample data.

Questions

Independent price verification questions from pricing and valuation teams

What is independent price verification?

Independent price verification (IPV) is the daily check that a fund's prices are right: each evaluated price is tested against independent evidence (a second vendor, dealer quotes, reported trades), and a price that does not hold up is challenged with the vendor or overridden with a second person's check. Independent Price Verification from Botminds runs that process with six agents that read each quote, explain or flag each move and run the vendor challenges, while the pricing analyst decides and a second person checks.

What are the steps in the independent price verification process?

The IPV process runs in order. Vendor files and broker runs come in and are mapped to each holding; each price is tested against its dealer spread and tolerance; moves the market explains are proposed for bulk acceptance; real outliers are challenged with the vendor; the analyst approves, keeps, overrides or holds with a reason code; a second person checks; and the Fund Controller locks and releases the prices for the NAV. Each step is on the audit trail.

How do you challenge a pricing vendor's evaluated price?

When the fund price sits outside the dealer spread by more than the tolerance, with at least three independent quotes, the Challenge agent drafts the challenge with the dealer evidence attached and the dealer median as the level asked. It is sent only when the analyst says yes, and the reply is tracked against a 60-minute rule, with a follow-up at 45 minutes and escalation 30 minutes before the lock. On the sample bond the vendor revised its price 53 minutes after the challenge was sent.

How does it support Rule 2a-5 fair value oversight and the valuation designee?

Under Rule 2a-5, the SEC's fair value rule, the valuation designee oversees its pricing services, with a process for initiating price challenges and named override authority. Each challenge and reply is counted by vendor and asset class, each override goes to a second person, and the Evidence agent drafts the monthly pricing-service oversight report from the challenge records, with a citation behind each number, for the Head of Valuation to sign.

How does it handle stale pricing and single-source prices?

The stale rule is set by asset class: three days for high yield, five for municipals and loans, one for Treasuries and listed equities. Stale and single-source prices are flagged and quotes are requested from dealers; a stale price the dealer runs disagree with can be challenged, as the 0.85% yen bond was after six unchanged days. On a single-source loan the portfolio manager's level is recorded as evidence only, and when nothing reliable arrives the analyst holds the prior price with reason HD-01 and the Valuation Manager's approval.

Can it read broker quotes from email in other languages?

Yes. The Quote agent reads runs from the shared pricing mailbox as tables, free text such as “99-11 / 99-19”, PDF attachments and spreadsheets, in the dealer's own language, and shows the original beside the English reading. A quote below 95% parse or 98% mapping confidence goes to the analyst to map.

Who decides a price, and who checks it?

The pricing analyst decides, and the Valuation Manager checks each override and each move above two points. Nobody checks their own work, portfolio managers supply quotes as evidence only, and only the Fund Controller locks and releases. The agents never accept a price, send a challenge unseen or edit a price.

How is it tested before it prices a live day?

The Agentic Solution Engine builds and deploys it from your requirements and documents (your pricing policy, source hierarchy and a past pricing day), and it goes live once each quality gate has passed. Setup ends with a test on a past day: on the sample, the agents raised each price the team had challenged, 49 of 49, and six more.

Run independent price checks
on one of your past pricing days.

We'll run Independent Price Verification on one of your own past pricing days: your vendor files, broker runs and tolerance policy.