SystemContract Manufacturing (CDMO)

Client Program Business Review

A quarterly business review drafted from the records: every batch of the client's year on one strip, a letter counted on the client's own definitions, challenged as the client would, and signed by four people.

See one client's review drafted, challenged and signed ↓
Watch with transcript →
The problem

The client found the number that did not match, and the meeting was about it

Each quarter the account team pulls batches, deviations, CAPAs, changes and supply dates from the MES, the batch records, the quality system, the lab system, the ERP and the client portal into slides. Right first time gets counted the plant's way, not the way the quality agreement defines it.

Facts the client must never see slip in: another client's batch on the same lot, the plant's own costs, people's names. And the client's hardest question arrives in the meeting, so the hour meant for the next program goes on reconciling the last one.

Built forAccount directorsClient quality liaisonsHeads of qualityPlanning heads

The Problem Today

Review numbers are copied from six systems by hand and counted the plant's way, so the meeting turns into a dispute over one figure.

7.7
EU GMP: the client monitors and reviews its contract plant published

Copied into slides by hand

  • Batches
  • Deviations
  • Changes
  • Dates
  • Two ways to count one measureThe plant's right first time differs from the agreement's
  • Internal facts slip throughAnother client's batch or the plant's costs reach a slide

The Solution

  1. The year read batch by batchEach batch a mark on the day it was made, with its outcome
  2. Counted on the agreed termsQuality measures from the quality agreement, delivery from the supply agreement
  3. Challenged as the client wouldThe client's hard questions asked first, the agents' own figures checked
  4. Signed, then sentPlanning, the liaison, quality and the account director, in turn

Built-in controls

  • Other clients' business kept out of each letter
  • The maker signs neither quality nor approval
  • A client's portal shows its batches alone

What You Get

Clients read their year batch by batch, and the meeting starts from the next program.

  • The client reads its own yearEach batch opens in its portal, beside the signed letter
  • Numbers the client can checkEach figure lights the batches it counts, on terms both signed
  • Each review teaches the nextA client's ask becomes a rule once the account director approves
Features

Quarterly business review features, from the year strip to the client's portal

A client's fourth-quarter review is due in its portal three business days before the meeting, and the liaison, planning, quality and the account director each take a part.

demoEvery batch, client, person and figure in this walkthrough is sample data.

  1. 01Year strip

    A client's year of batches on one strip, beside the review letter it backs

    • One mark per batch. Each batch sits on the day it was made, marked right first time, deviation, on hold, rejected or in review, so the year is read before a word is written.
    • The letter written beside it. The review letter follows the meeting's agenda, and each number in it lights the batches it counts on the strip above.
    • An error in our own figures flagged. When the challenger finds a wrong figure, a banner says so above the strip before anyone is asked to sign.
  2. 02Agents

    Each agent's plan, sources and confidence, and rules learned from past reviews

    • Sources a click away. Each agent lists what it read and what it concluded, so the liaison checks the work behind a figure instead of trusting it.
    • Rules that carry to the next quarter. A client's ask from one review, such as splitting each measure by product, becomes a rule once the account director approves it.
  3. 03Client questions

    Client questions answered before the meeting, the agents' own error included

    • The client's hardest questions first. The challenger asks what the client's head of external manufacturing would, and each answer links to the letter section that settles it.
    • A held batch counted wrongly. The draft counted a batch right first time from its release record after an impact assessment had pulled it into a deviation; the fix moved the quarter.
    • Supply questions left to planning. Whether the plant can make every batch a client asks for is marked for the head of production planning to confirm, and no agent answers it.
  4. 04Measures

    Right first time and on-time release counted on the client's agreed terms

    • Quality and delivery kept apart. Right first time and the deviation rate follow the quality agreement both quality units signed; on-time release follows the supply agreement the account leads signed.
    • Each figure opens its batches. Clicking a count lights the batches behind it, so a disputed number becomes a list both sides can read.
  5. 05Kept out

    Confidential client information kept out of the letter, with each replacement

    • Another client's business stays out. A shared binder lot, another product on the same line and the plant's own costs are replaced with the sentence the client is owed, or removed.
    • What the client is owed stays in. Deviations, holds, rejections, late batches and notices due under the quality agreement remain in the letter.
  6. 06Client note

    The client's free-text note opened by the liaison, who assigns its answer

    • Read by a person. The agents do not read client free text; the liaison reads it and picks an action from a fixed list.
    • An answer given an owner and due date. Answering separately creates a dated item with an owner, so the client's question is tracked instead of lost in an email thread.
  7. 07Supply confirmed

    Supply commitments confirmed by planning, conditional on a held material lot

    • The plan and the hold opened first. The head of production planning opens the approved plan and the hold on the active lot before confirming what the letter commits.
    • A held lot stated plainly. The letter tells the client the active lot is on hold and that each date resting on it is conditional, with the day its results are due.
  8. 08Sign and send

    Business review letter signed in sequence and sent to the client's portal

    • One maker, three checkers. Planning confirms supply, the liaison marks the letter prepared, quality signs its own section, and the account director approves.
    • Any change clears the signatures. A fix, a typed sentence or a send-back after a signature clears it and moves the version, and a send-back closes only once its sender has read the answer.
    • Delivered with a receipt. The approved letter and strip reach the client's portal ahead of the deadline the supply agreement sets, and the receipt stays on record.
  9. 09Client portal

    Client portal showing its own year of batches and the signed letter

    • Only its own batches. The client's head of external manufacturing sees its strip and letter with no internal markers, and can open any of its batches.
    • Answers in fixed fields. Pre-read accepted or changes needed, topics to add and who will attend come back to the liaison as fields.

Account directors see each client's letter deadline in one list

The liaison prepares, planning commits supply, the head of quality owns what is said about quality, and the account director decides what goes to the client.

Client account directors

Own each client relationship, approve and send the review

  • Approval only after the other signatures
  • Each client review's clock in one list
  • Learned rules and settings to approve
Client quality liaisons

Prepare each client's review and close its questions

  • A drafted letter with every figure sourced
  • The client's questions asked before the meeting
  • Client notes read and assigned by them
Heads of quality

Sign what the review says about quality

  • The quality section to read before signing
  • Measures on the agreed quality definitions
  • A send-back that needs a real answer
Heads of production planning

Confirm the supply the letter commits

  • The approved plan and any hold, opened first
  • Supply questions routed to them alone
  • Conditional dates stated as conditional

The draft's quarter read 7 of 10 right first time; the batch records said 6

A batch on hold counted right first time

The calculator read one batch from its release record and missed that the morning's impact assessment had brought it into a deviation; the quarter fell from 7 of 10 to 6 of 10.

An active lot on hold behind the supply plan

The letter states the hold and that the dates resting on the lot are conditional, and the notice owed under clause 6.4 joins the commitments.

One deviation behind only some misses

Of the 4 fourth-quarter batches that were not right first time, one deviation explains 2; the other two carry deviations of their own, and the letter names both.

A client question that could have vanished

The client's note about the qualification batches became a dated item with an owner, answered outside the letter.

demoSample data, from the working solution.

More screens

Five clients, four reviews a year each, on each client's own definitions

The strip before any agent reads, every client review and its clock, the client's answer, and the settings that hold the clocks.

Nothing shown before the readBefore the agents read the records, every lane says not read yet and the letter is not drafted, so no number is assumed.
Every client QBR due in 30 daysEach client's review with its meeting, letter deadline and business days left, one blocked with its reason, and 5 clients × 4 quarterly reviews = 20 a year.
The client's answer, in fieldsThe client accepted the letter as the pre-read, added the December plan as a topic and named 4 attendees, all as fields the liaison reads.
Clocks, roles and locked definitionsThe letter deadline and reading time, residency and retention, who signs what, learned rules, and measure definitions that change only with both parties.

demoSample data, from the working solution.

The letter cannot be marked prepared while a client note sits unread

Head of production planning
Sees
The approved plan and the hold on the lot behind it
Signs
The supply section, confirming what the letter commits
Client quality liaison
Sees
Each challenger point closed and the client's note assigned
Signs
The letter as prepared, the maker's signature
Head of quality
Sees
The quality section, open for the set reading time
Signs
The quality section, or a send-back naming the section and reason
Client account director
Sees
The whole letter, after the three signatures before it
Signs
Approval, then sending to the client's portal

Six systems read once, and each sentence in the letter cites one of them

Batch records and statusesEvery batch of the client's year from the MES and the electronic batch records.
Deviations, CAPAs and change controlsThe quality system's events on the client's batches and its changes needing approval.
Release resultsDisposition and release dates from the lab system.
Orders and promised datesConfirmed dates from the ERP, the basis of on-time release.
Quality and supply agreementsThe signed measure definitions and the review clause.
The client's agendaQuestions sent through the client portal as fields.

Questions account teams ask before a quarterly business review

What is a quarterly business review for a CDMO?

A quarterly business review is the meeting where a contract manufacturer and its client go through the program: what was made and released, right first time, deviations and CAPAs, changes needing the client, and supply. Here agents draft the written review from the records, and four people sign it before it reaches the client's portal.

Why does a client run a supplier performance review of its CDMO?

EU GMP's chapter on outsourced activities has the contract giver monitor and review how its contract acceptor performs, and ICH Q10 covers the monitoring of outsourced work. FDA treats a contract facility as part of the owner's own manufacturing.

How is right first time defined in a business review?

On the definition the client signed. Here it is batches released with no deviation, out-of-specification result or rework, over batches with a known outcome, set in the quality agreement's measures. On-time release sits in the supply agreement, because delivery is a business term.

What is kept out of a client's review?

Other clients' batches, products and line use, the plant's costs and prices, and the names of people outside the review team. A deviation, hold, rejection, late batch or notice the client is owed stays in.

Can a reviewer send a section back?

Yes. The head of quality or the account director names the section and the reason. The liaison opens the batches it counts, revises it or answers in writing, and runs the challenger's recheck, and only the sender closes it.

Bring the review
you are dreading next quarter.

Send one client's batch list, quality agreement measures and last review deck, and we will draft the letter from the records.