SearchPersonal Injury & Mass Torts

Personal Injury Case Valuation

Personal injury case valuation software that puts each comparable verdict and settlement for the same injury and courts on one plot, cited, under a value range the trial attorney can defend at mediation.

Walk the valuation from case file to signed memo ↓
Watch with transcript →
The problem

A demand built on a handful of verdicts and a multiple of the bills

A case analyst searches verdict reporters by hand, reads the summaries, and adjusts old awards and different medical bills by eye. Five or six results that look like the client get pasted into a memo, and nobody writes down the ones left out.

Across the table, the adjuster prices the claim off the medical specials, with a database behind it, and a mediator discounts a number that reads like opinion. Keep or drop one big verdict without saying why, and the demand moves by six figures before anyone sees it happen.

Built forTrial attorneysCase analystsManaging partnersInjured clients

The Problem Today

Almost every injury case settles, and the insurer prices it as a multiple of the medical bills.

96%
of tort cases in state courts end without a trial published

Rebuilt from scratch for each case

  • Verdicts
  • Summaries
  • Adjustments
  • Memo
  • Outliers moved in silenceOne verdict kept or dropped shifts the demand, with no reason on file
  • A few cases, picked to fitFive or six picked to fit, and the rest go unrecorded

The Solution

  1. Comparables found and scoredSame injury and courts, scored for how close each is
  2. Adjusted to this caseToday’s dollars and this client’s medical specials
  3. Outlier dropped, with a reasonThe band re-counts on screen and the memo follows
  4. Range approved and signedSigned by the attorney; settling is the client’s call

Built-in controls

  • Only an attorney drops a comparable
  • Confidential settlements stay unnamed outside the firm
  • Medical records opened only under the client’s authorization

What You Get

Firms walk into mediation with a range a mediator can check, and each excluded case is explained.

<1 hour
of analyst time per valuation, down from 6–10 our estimate
  • Settle-or-try in one viewExpected trial value set against the range
  • A memo that follows the plotDrop a comparable and the paragraph re-counts
  • The client decidesA plain letter asks for settlement authority
Nine screens, one valuation

Personal injury case valuation software, from case file to signed range

From the case file to the client’s letter: the specials, the comparables, the outliers, the drivers and the range, each screen with the role that works it.

  1. 01Specials, cited to the bill

    A case profile from the file, each bill cited to its page

    How it works

    • Reads the chronology, the medical bills, the police report and the wage records
    • Builds the profile: injury, surgery, age, venue, defendant and specials
    • $97,300 billed plus $20,700 of lost wages makes $118,000 of specials
    • Click the specials and the billing summary opens at its page

    Case analystNo more retyping the specials from the billing ledger into a valuation sheet, and anyone can check where each dollar came from.

  2. 02Comparables found

    A comparables search across reporters, court records and the firm’s ledger

    How it works

    • Searches two verdict reporters, public court records and the firm’s own settlement ledger
    • Scores each result on injury, venue, age and specials
    • Keeps 63 of 211 shoulder results at a closeness of 0.45 or more: 41 settlements, 17 plaintiff and 5 defense verdicts
    • Search again reruns it and reports anything new

    Case analystGets back the half of the week spent reading verdict summaries to find a few that look like the client.

  3. 03Comparables plot

    Each comparable a dot, placed at its value adjusted to this case

    How it works

    • Three rows: settlements, plaintiff verdicts and defense verdicts
    • Each dot sits at its award in current dollars and at this case’s specials, sized by its medical bills
    • The proposed range is drawn as a band across the rows
    • Click a dot to see its closeness: 0.99 for a store-aisle fall with the same surgery

    Trial attorneySees the whole field of results for a repaired rotator cuff in her courts at once, where a memo used to cite the few someone remembered.

  4. 04Outlier explained

    An outlier flagged as close on paper and different in fact

    How it works

    • Looks for punitive damages, a second surgery or another state’s law
    • C-47 scores 0.81: a $2,350,000 verdict, $3,022,800 once adjusted
    • $900,000 of that verdict was punitive damages against a drunk driver
    • It recommends a drop and leaves the call to the attorney

    Trial attorneyLearns before mediation which verdict is stretching her band and why, before defense counsel raises it at the table.

  5. 05Band after the drop

    Drop a comparable with a reason and watch the band re-count

    How it works

    • Drops are the trial attorney’s alone, each with a chosen reason
    • Without C-47 the band moves from $405,000–690,000 to $410,000–640,000
    • The midpoint falls from $528,000 to $512,000, on 62 of 63 comparables
    • The memo paragraph under the plot rewrites itself and names the drop

    Trial attorneyCan show a mediator what one excluded verdict did to the number, with the reason on the record, so the drop reads as judgment.

  6. 06Value drivers

    Value drivers measured across the comparables that share them

    How it works

    • Measured across 62 comparables: surgical repair adds 38%, a commercial defendant 15%
    • Clear liability adds 8%, cited to the police report
    • A prior strain to the same shoulder takes off 24%, and a 23-day gap in care 20%
    • On the plot lights up the comparables that share a driver

    Trial attorneyWalks in ready for the adjuster’s two attacks, the old shoulder strain and the gap in care, with the answer to each already found in the file.

  7. 07Range explained

    A range that shows what would move it before the mediator asks

    How it works

    • Found, adjusted, weighted, banded: 63 found, 57 awards weighted, the middle half kept
    • Re-counts the band without the out-of-state venues, with one county only, or since 2021
    • One county alone gives $410,000–635,000, close to the full set
    • The trial attorney approves the range with a note for the file

    Managing partnerSees, before co-signing a $720,000 opening, that the band holds when the comparables are narrowed, so the firm can answer a charge of cherry-picking.

  8. 08Signed valuation memo

    A valuation memo that cites each figure and names what was dropped

    How it works

    • Drafted from the plot, the drivers and the venue history
    • Each fact links to its page in the police report, the chronology or the billing summary
    • Cites 69 sources, and counts 12 confidential firm settlements without naming them
    • Switches between the internal memo and the mediation statement

    Trial attorneySigns a memo that already agrees with the plot, with no paragraphs to rewrite each time a comparable goes in or out.

  9. 09Letter to the client

    A settlement authority letter the client can read in one sitting

    How it works

    • Drafted in plain words from the approved range and the latest offer
    • Sets the $210,000 offer against a fair range of $410,000 to 640,000
    • Suggests a floor of $450,000 and says the decision is the client’s
    • Waits for the attorney to approve it before it is sent

    ClientGets a fair number and the reason for it in words an injured warehouse worker can follow alone, and makes the call himself.

Settle inside the band, or try the case for about $402,700

The settle-or-try view on the range screen, from the 21 verdicts left once C-47 is out.

What the range screen weighsFor this case
Proposed range at mediation$410,000 to 640,000
Insurer’s latest offer$210,000, about 1.8 times specials
Plaintiff wins among the remaining verdicts16 of 21, or 76%
Median plaintiff verdict, adjusted$528,500
Expected value at trialAbout $402,700
Still to spend on a trialAbout $68,000 and about 14 more months
Around the plot

The court record, the venues and the offers behind one shoulder valuation

What the analyst, the attorney and the managing partner check beside the band.

The verdict at its sourceRead the source opens the public court record at the judgment line: $1,450,000 compensatory and $900,000 punitive.
Three reasons to choose fromA drop takes a reason and the trial attorney’s sign-in. The reason travels into the memo and the audit trail.
Who else had a prior injuryThe prior-injury driver lit on the plot. The 10 of 62 comparables that share it stand out, so the attorney sees where they landed.
Six venues and their juriesComparables, settlements and verdicts by venue, the median adjusted value and the plaintiff win rate, with verdicts by year since 2018.
Offers against the bandThe demand, the counter and both offers on one axis, with the demand window and the mediation marked. The best offer still sits below the band.
Who did what, and whyEach search, flag, drop, approval and signature in order, with agents shown apart from people. The record stays for seven years once the case closes.

The number stays with the attorney, and the settlement with the client

Agents find, score, explain and draft. People make the calls below.

Dropping a comparableOnly the trial attorney drops one, and only with a reason. The case analyst can flag a result but cannot drop it.
Approving the rangeThe trial attorney approves the band, with a note, and signs the memo.
Large openingsThe managing partner co-signs any demand or mediation opening above $500,000.
SettlingThe client decides whether to settle and at what floor. The letter asks; it does not decide.
Contact with the insurer and the mediatorAgents do not write to the client, the insurer or the mediator. A person sends each letter and each statement.

Seven agents that score and explain, while the attorney keeps the drop

Each one reads, finds, measures or drafts, and each stops short of a decision.

Case reader

Reads the chronology, bills, police report and wage records, and builds the case profile with each fact cited.

  • Never changes a billed amount
Comparables finder

Searches verdict and settlement reports, public court records and the firm’s settlement ledger, and scores closeness.

  • Never uses a result it cannot cite
Outlier checker

Flags results that are close on paper but different in fact: punitive damages, a second surgery, another state’s law.

  • Never drops a comparable: it explains and asks
Driver analyst

Explains the facts that raise or lower value, from the comparables and the case file.

  • Never sets the number
Range builder

Adjusts each award to today’s dollars and this case’s specials, draws the weighted band, and re-counts it after a drop.

  • Never hides a dropped comparable from the memo
Memo writer

Drafts the valuation memo, the mediation statement and the client’s authority letter, with a citation behind each figure.

  • Leaves sending to a person
  • Never names a confidential settlement outside the firm
Offer tracker

Logs demands and offers, the demand window and the mediation date, and sets each offer against the band.

  • Never answers an offer

Personal injury case valuation software: what the trial team asks

What is personal injury case valuation software?

Personal injury case valuation software finds comparable verdicts and settlements for the same injury and venue, adjusts each to the case at hand, and explains a value range. Here, agents read the case file, search the reports and the firm’s ledger, and draw a weighted band; the trial attorney decides which outliers to drop and why, approves the range and signs the memo.

How is an old award made comparable to this case?

Each award is brought to today’s dollars with the consumer price index and scaled to this case’s medical specials. Closeness is scored on injury, venue, specials and age, and the band is the weighted middle half of the comparables.

What happens to a verdict that would inflate the range?

The outlier checker flags it and says why, such as punitive damages or a second surgery. It stays on the plot until the trial attorney drops it, giving a reason; the memo then names both.

Are the firm’s confidential settlements exposed in a mediation statement?

No. Settlements from the firm’s own ledger count toward the band, but the mediation statement leaves their names out. The internal valuation memo keeps them for the firm.

What does a prior injury or a gap in treatment do to the number?

The driver analyst measures each driver across the comparables that share it and cites where the file proves it. The attorney sees how far it pulls the value down, and the record that answers it.

Can the client see why the number is what it is?

Yes. The memo writer drafts a plain-words letter with the range, the latest offer and a suggested floor, and it says the decision is the client’s. The attorney approves the letter before it is sent.

Does a client’s file feed model training?

No. A matter’s records live in the firm’s workspace for that case; no model is taught on them.

Plot a case you have already settled
and see whether its number held.

Pick a case your firm has resolved, and we will put its comparables, its band and its memo on screen beside the number you reached.