He said he never approved splitting an order. The approval log shows four orders approved under his login between 14:02 and 14:13, $99,250 in all, each under the $25,000 plant limit.
How a witness interview memo goes from the plan to the signature
The interview plan first and the signature last, as the matter runs them, with the role each screen serves.
- 01Interview plan
A plan board that staffs each interview and shows each memo’s status
How it works
- Each witness in order, with the lawyer leading, the note-taker and the memo status
- Whether the witness brings personal counsel, noted before anyone enters the room
- The issues the interviews must establish, each with the evidence so far
- The next guide built from the matter’s issues, earlier memos and exhibits
Practice chairStaffs twelve interviews in nine days and sees at a glance which memos are signed and who sits next.
- 02Documents to show
An exhibit list with the reason each document is shown
How it works
- Bates number, date, the reason it is shown and the question it serves
- Proposed by an agent, approved by the lawyer leading the interview
- The minute each exhibit was shown, stamped as the notes come in
- The hotline report stays off the table, with the reporter’s name masked
Investigations counselWalks into the room with a binder in the order of the guide, and can show later which document the witness saw and when.
- 03Recording the warning
Upjohn warning recorded word for word before the first question
How it works
- Firm text v3 read in full and stored exactly as written
- The time it was given and the time it was acknowledged, both 10:02
- The witness’s answer and counsel’s reply, each in their own words
- The guide’s questions stay locked until this is saved
Investigations associatePuts more than a one-line note in the file, so the privilege holds up if a witness later says he thought counsel was his lawyer.
- 04Interview guide
A live guide that ticks each answer and each exhibit to the minute
How it works
- 24 questions in 6 topics, ticked as the note-taker types
- Each exhibit shown carries its minute, from 10:06 to 10:45
- 21 of 24 answered when the interview closed after 58 minutes
- The 3 questions not reached are flagged and become follow-ups
Investigations associateKeeps typing in the room while the guide keeps count, so no topic slips by and no exhibit goes unlogged.
- 05Notes, line by line
Typed notes stamped to the minute, with each correction kept on file
How it works
- Each line carries its minute, its speaker, its question and any exhibit
- 112 lines in all, with routine lines kept but not shown
- A quote total of 99,520 corrected to 99,250, checked against D-07
- The tracker adds nothing that was not typed
Investigations associateFixes a misheard figure against the exhibit itself before the memo is drafted, instead of from memory later in the week.
- 06A cited paragraph
A memo in the firm’s format, each paragraph cited to the minute of the notes
How it works
- Privilege header, attendees, the warning word for word, statements by topic
- 41 of 41 paragraphs cited to the minute, 14 cites to exhibits
- Click a minute to read the note line behind the paragraph
- Drafted 8 minutes after the interview ended
Investigations counselEdits a draft whose every paragraph traces back to what was typed in the room, and it reads as a summary rather than a transcript.
- 07Contradictions
A contradiction check against the exhibits and the matter’s earlier memos
How it works
- Each statement shown with its minute, beside the record it conflicts with
- Checked against 14 documents and 10 earlier memos in the matter
- Four approvals under his login in 11 minutes, against his denial
- Sources sit side by side for counsel to weigh, with no accusation
Investigations counselSees the conflict with an earlier witness as soon as the interview ends, not whenever someone happens to reread that memo.
- 08Follow-ups
Follow-up questions routed to the next interview once counsel approves
How it works
- Questions not reached and contradictions turned into follow-up questions
- Each routed to the next interview, a re-interview or a document request
- Counsel approves or drops each one, and a drop carries its reason
- No question tells a witness what another witness said
Investigations counselGoes into the subject’s interview with the gaps of earlier ones already in the guide, and no outline to rebuild.
- 09Signed memo
A signature that stays shut until the warning and acknowledgment are in
How it works
- Seven checks before signing, each with the detail behind its tick
- No signature without the recorded warning and the witness’s own words
- The note-taker’s review of the notes is one of the seven
- Signed on the day by the lawyer who led the interview
Investigations counselSigns a six-page memo on the day of the interview, with the warning on the record and nothing carried into the following week.