WorkflowAPI & Drug Substance

Impurity Risk Assessment (ICH M7, Q3C, Q3D)

A mutagenic impurity assessment solution for API manufacturers and CDMOs. Agents place each substance the route touches beside the record line that names it, run a rule-based and a statistical prediction on each organic structure, and follow each potential mutagen downhill to its limit. A challenger agent argues against the draft before the toxicologist and the quality unit sign.

See one route cleared substance by substance ↓
Watch with transcript →
The problem

The reasoning that clears a route sits in two people's spreadsheets

A drug substance route touches starting materials, reagents, catalysts, solvents, intermediates, by-products and whatever forms in the last stage. Someone has to say which could be mutagenic, which solvents remain and under what limit, and what the active adds to the client's elemental assessment, before the client files.

It is done in a spreadsheet, a stack of prediction printouts and a word processor. The argument that clears an impurity without a test is a column of factors only its two authors can defend, and when a catalyst lot changes nothing says it has gone stale.

Then the questions arrive: where a figure came from, and why an impurity that forms in the last stage was argued away instead of tested.

Built forImpurity risk assessorsToxicologist reviewersPlant QA headsQuality control laboratory heads

The Problem Today

A route carries dozens of substances, and the reasoning that clears each one lives with the two experts who wrote it.

2
prediction methods per structure, by ICH M7 published
1.5 µg
a day, the lifetime intake for one impurity, ICH M7 published

Joined by hand, four at a time

  • Route
  • Predicts
  • Results
  • Supplier
  • A supplier change voids it quietlyNothing says the argument has gone stale
  • The last stage gets argued awayWhat forms at the end is hardest to defend

The Solution

  1. Each substance placedRead from the route and the batch records, by origin, with its line
  2. Two methods, one reviewWhere the methods clash, the drafted review says why, and a toxicologist signs
  3. Followed downhillEach stage's factor opens into its parts and the instruction that earned it
  4. Above the line, a testA stair that stops high sets a test, and the challenger attacks it first

Built-in controls

  • Each factor opens the record line behind it
  • The preparer and the approver are two people
  • A signature lapses when its basis changes

What You Get

Impurity reasoning stops being private knowledge and becomes a method a reviewer can audit and a new assessor can run.

  • Asked before the agency asksThe challenger's points travel with the assessment
  • One register, each changeA supplier change re-runs it instead of restarting it
  • The client replies in fieldsIts toxicologist's answer lands on the limit the same day
Features

A mutagenic impurity assessment for one route, screen by screen

The assessor runs the route, the toxicologist signs each expert review, the laboratory head accepts each test method, and the plant's quality head approves what is filed.

demoA sample plant and a sample client: the active, the batches, the results and the people shown here are invented.

  1. 01Purge staircase

    Mutagenic impurity assessment drawn as a staircase down to the limit

    • One stair per potential mutagen. Each impurity is drawn from where it enters the route to the level predicted in the active, so an assessor sees which ones an argument can carry.
    • The limit line across the chart. A stair ending under the line is an argument; one stopping above it is a test, so the analytical work a filing needs is known early.
  2. 02Factor parts

    Purge factor calculation opened part by part

    • The sum, not the answer. A factor shows the parts it is made of and the route record step that earned each one, so a reviewer argues with the chemistry.
    • No credit inside the forming stage. An impurity forming in the same vessel earns no solubility credit there, the hole inspectors look for in a purge argument.
  3. 03Register

    Each substance the route touches, by origin, with its record line

    • Materials, reagents and by-products in one list. The impurities a starting material brings in sit beside the reagents and the compounds that can form, which is where mapping goes short.
    • A source line on each row. An entry names the record it was read from, so no line on the list rests on an assessor's recollection.
  4. 04Both methods

    Expert review where a rule-based and a statistical prediction disagree

    • Both reports side by side. The alert, its reasoning, the statistical call and its domain sit on one screen, and the reviewer opens each report before signing.
    • A disagreement is a question. The drafted review says why the alert cannot be dismissed from prediction alone, keeps the class, and asks for a bacterial reverse mutation test.
  5. 05Intake ladder

    Acceptable intake and the parts per million it becomes at this dose

    • The limit shown as a division. The intake, the maximum daily dose and the parts per million they give are one visible sum, so no filed limit hides its arithmetic.
    • Duration decides the intake. Clinical batches are judged against the intake for the dosing period they support, the marketed product against the lifetime figure.
  6. 06Challenger

    A challenger agent argues the draft back, our own arguments included

    • The draft read as the agency reads it. A point names what the draft says and what it should say, so the assessor meets the hard questions before an outside reviewer does.
    • Two points are the agents' own errors. A solubility credit claimed inside the forming stage, and a drug-product threshold applied to the active, are caught here rather than in an information request.
  7. 07Ledgers

    Residual solvent limits and the elemental impurity risk assessment part

    • Solvents by class, with the last batches. A solvent carries its limit and the plant's results as a share of it, so a missing residual solvent test shows as a gap.
    • The contribution, not the concentration. The elemental part is computed as micrograms a day at the product's dose, keeping the drug-product threshold off the active.
  8. 08Rehearsal

    Rehearse a hold-time change and watch the predicted level move

    • Assumptions on screen and editable. The formation rate, the hold and the factor for the range edges are shown, and changing one recomputes the result as a sum.
    • A rehearsal moves nothing. The assessment keeps its figure until a change control is approved and it is re-run, so a what-if cannot reach a filing.
  9. 09The draft

    The three assessments as they will be filed, sentence by sentence

    • One sentence, one piece of evidence. The writer draws on signed reviews and sourced results, and a reviewer or an inspector opens the evidence under any sentence.
    • A method that reaches the limit. The laboratory head accepts each test and its quantitation limit, or sends it back with a reason, before the section can be prepared.

The assessor prepares, the toxicologist signs, quality approves

One assessment, four signers, each signing only what is theirs.

Impurity risk assessors

Write the three assessments for each active and re-run them on a change

  • Each substance placed with its record line
  • Purge arguments a reviewer can open
  • The hard questions raised before filing
Toxicologist reviewers

Sign each expert review where the methods alert, clash or fall out of domain

  • Both reports opened before a signature
  • A drafted review with its evidence
  • A test asked for where prediction cannot decide
Plant QA heads

Approve each assessment for the plant's own part and own its rules

  • The challenger log beside the draft
  • Later changes clearing what rests on them
  • An evidence pack to hand over
Quality control laboratory heads

Accept or refuse each test method and the quantitation limit it reaches

  • A limit beside the method that measures it
  • A reason code for sending a test back
  • Methods still in validation marked as such

Nine agents read, predict, compute and argue; none of them signs

Each agent shows the records it opened and the call it made, and each has work it may not do.

Route reader

Lists the substances in the route from the route record, the development report and the material specifications.

  • Never invents a substance no record names
  • Never credits a physical step the route lacks
Rule-based prediction runner

Runs the expert rule-based method on each organic structure and keeps the alert with its reasoning.

  • Never overrides an alert
  • Never runs on a structure it cannot read
Statistical prediction runner

Runs the statistical method and records the call with its domain and its confidence.

  • Never reports an out-of-domain call as negative
Expert-review drafter

Drafts the review wherever the methods alert, disagree or fall out of domain, with its evidence.

  • Never signs
  • Never clears a structure a method alerts on
Purge calculator

Builds a staircase from the four physical parts and compares the purge predicted with the purge required.

  • Never credits solubility inside the forming stage
  • Never credits a factor with no route line behind it
Ledger calculator

Fills the solvent ledger by class and the element ledger from the laboratory results, and computes the plant's part.

  • Never puts the drug-product threshold on the active
  • Never uses an unsigned result
Challenger

Attacks the draft as the agency's toxicologist would, the agents' own arguments included.

  • Never settles a point of its own
Outside agent

Drafts and tracks requests to the contract laboratory, the supplier and the client, and reads a reply as fields.

  • Never accepts free text as data
  • Never moves a number without a field and a document
Assessment writer

Writes the three assessments from signed reviews and sourced results, one sentence to one source.

  • Never writes a sentence with no evidence
  • Never prepares or approves
More screens

Fixing one challenger point moves the staircase and the filed text

Past the first walk: the fix that changes a number, the requests that leave as fields, the toxicologist's signature, and the trail behind it.

The draft changed, and by how muchFixing the solubility credit takes the level predicted in the active from 0.70 ppm to 7.0 ppm, above the limit.
Requests leave as fields, and a typed note stops a sectionThe mutation test request and the answered catalyst questionnaire; the free-text line the supplier added blocks the elemental section until somebody opens it.
Signed by the toxicologist, both reports opened firstThe signature carries its meaning and the reports read before it: the alert stands, a test is set at the intermediate and a mutation test is requested.
Ten assessments across three plants and three clientsEach one shows why it runs, what it waits on and who owns it; an assessment owned by another plant is read-only here.
The change watcher starts the re-run, and the client is toldAn open change says what it does to this assessment and whether it re-runs it; a solvent change touching another active has no effect here.
Each record opened before the signature that rests on itThe run, the two draft fixes with their reasons, the rehearsal and the steer, each line carrying what its signature meant.

demoSample data, from the working solution.

What no agent decides: the class, the specification and the method

Concluding no mutagenic concernWhere a method alerts, the class waits for a toxicologist who has read both reports.
Approving the assessmentThe assessor prepares and the plant's quality head approves after opening the draft and the challenger log.
Accepting a test methodThe laboratory head decides whether a method reaches the limit, and can refuse it with a reason.
Setting the client's specificationThe client owns its specification and its filing; the plant supplies its own part.
Reading typed text as dataA note, a reason or an edited sentence is marked as unchecked words and reaches a second named person.

The route record, the plant's own results and the supplier's fields

Route record and development reportStages, charges, quenches, washes and holds, by step
Material and product specificationsImpurities specified in starting materials, and the active's limits
Laboratory and chromatography systemsSolvent, element and impurity results by batch, with their methods
Structure-based prediction resultsOne rule-based and one statistical call per structure, with its domain
Supplier certificates and questionnaire fieldsElements added on purpose, and what a catalyst brings with it
Change control recordsOpen changes that touch impurities, and what each re-runs

What assessors and toxicologists ask about impurity assessments

What is a mutagenic impurity assessment?

A mutagenic impurity assessment places each substance a route can leave in the drug substance, judges which could be DNA reactive, sets an acceptable intake and the limit it becomes at the product's daily dose, and says how each one is controlled. Here agents draft it from the route record and the plant's own results.

Does it decide the class of an impurity?

No. Both prediction methods run on each organic structure, and where they alert, disagree or fall outside the model's domain, an agent drafts the review with the evidence on both sides. The toxicologist opens both reports and signs.

How is a purge argument supported without a test?

A stage's factor is built from the physical parts that earn it, and a part names the step of the route record behind it. The ratio between the purge predicted and the purge required decides whether the claim stands on reasoning or needs spiking data.

What about an impurity that forms in the last stage?

It earns no purge credit inside the stage that forms it. The assessment sets a test in the drug substance and ties the condition that drives the formation, such as the hold before crystallization, to the limit.

Who signs the elemental part when it is the client's assessment?

The elemental guideline is written for the drug product, so the plant supplies its contribution in micrograms a day and names what belongs to the client. The plant's quality head approves the plant's part; the client decides its specification.

What happens when a supplier or a process changes?

The change watcher reads the quality system and starts the re-run for anything that can touch impurities. A signature resting on what changed is cleared, the export shows as unsigned, and the client hears within the period its quality agreement sets.

Bring one route record
and its laboratory results.

Send one route record, the specifications of its starting materials and the last batches' solvent and element results, and we will build its staircases.